Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Are Doberman Pinschers good guard dogs?

Hey guys,

I'm currently in the market for a new guard dog and I've been considering getting a Doberman Pinscher. I've heard mixed things about the breed's temperament and I'm wondering if they are actually good guard dogs? I live in a high crime area and would like a dog that can protect my property and family if need be. Can anyone share their experiences with Dobermans as guard dogs? Are they easy to train for protection work? Any insight would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

All Replies


Hi there,

As someone who has owned a Doberman Pinscher as a guard dog, I can confidently say that they are excellent protectors. A well-trained Doberman is fearless, alert, and always ready to defend their family and property. My Dobie was incredibly loyal and became very attached to my family, which made him even more protective.

In terms of training, I found that positive reinforcement was the best approach with my Dobie. He responded well to reward-based training and enjoyed the mental stimulation that came with learning new commands. However, I will say that Dobermans can be strong-willed and require an owner who is firm and consistent with their training.

One thing to keep in mind when considering a Doberman Pinscher as a guard dog is their size. Dobies are a large breed and require plenty of space to move around and exercise. They are not well-suited for apartments or small homes, and their exercise needs should be considered before bringing one into the family.

Overall, I would recommend a Doberman Pinscher as a guard dog to anyone who is willing to put in the time and effort to properly train and socialize them. With proper training and socialization, Dobermans can make excellent family pets and loyal protectors.


Hello everyone,

I've owned seven Dobermans in my lifetime and can say with confidence that they are great guard dogs. Dobermans have a natural instinct to protect their owners, and being bred specifically for guarding makes them one of the best choices for the job. These dogs are known for their intelligence, loyalty, and courage and can be trained to handle any type of situation.

In terms of training, I believe the key with Dobermans is consistency. They are smart and eager to please, but if they think they can get away with something, they will. So it's essential to reinforce their training every day and make sure everyone in the house is on the same page. Early socialization is also crucial to ensure that they are comfortable in new situations and not overly aggressive towards people or other animals.

Another thing to consider when thinking about getting a Doberman as a guard dog is their exercise needs. These dogs are high-energy and require regular exercise to keep them happy and healthy. A bored and under-exercised Doberman may become destructive or overly aggressive, so it's crucial to make sure they get enough physical and mental stimulation.

Overall, I highly recommend Doberman Pinschers as guard dogs, given their natural instincts and trainability. But, as always, proper training, socialization, and exercise are key to ensuring that they are well-adjusted and well-behaved family members.


Hey there forum!

I have had a Doberman Pinscher for over 10 years now and I can tell you from experience that they make great guard dogs. While they can be very intimidating to strangers and would-be intruders, around people they know they can be very affectionate as well. My Dobie constantly patrols the property, watching everything closely, and is quick to alert me if she senses something is wrong. Her bark alone is enough to make anyone think twice before trying anything suspicious.

In terms of training, I will say that Dobies can be stubborn at times, but they are also very intelligent and willing to learn. In my case, I was able to train my Dobie to be an excellent watchguard with the help of some positive reinforcement and treats. However, one thing I have learned is that consistency is key. You need to be very clear with your Dog so that they understand their role is to protect you and your family. In my opinion, any dog can be a good guard dog, but it all comes down to the training and time you invest in them.

Lastly, I would just like to emphasize the importance of socializing your Dobie from a young age. They can sometimes be territorial, as other users here have stated, so it's crucial to train them to interact properly with people and other dogs. Overall, I highly recommend a Doberman Pinscher to anyone looking for a loyal and effective guard dog.


Hi everyone,

I've been researching Doberman Pinschers as a potential guard dog for my family and came across this thread. From what I've read, it seems like they have a strong reputation as protectors, but I was wondering if they are good with children?

I have a young daughter, and her safety is my top priority. I want a dog that can protect her if need be, but will also be gentle and patient with her. Can anyone share their experiences with Dobermans and children? Are they good family pets, or are they better suited as guard dogs for adult-only homes?

Thanks in advance for your insights.


Hey there,

I've been a Doberman Pinscher owner for nearly a decade now, and I can confirm that they can make excellent family pets as well as great guard dogs. In my experience, Dobermans can be very affectionate and gentle towards children if they are socialized properly from a young age.

They are known to be very protective of their families, which can translate to being protective of kids as well. However, it's crucial to supervise interactions between children and dogs to avoid any rough play that could result in an injury. Dobermans are relatively large dogs, so it's important to teach your children how to interact with them safely and respectfully to minimize any risks.

Training is key when it comes to raising a Doberman with children. They need to learn basic obedience commands like "sit" or "stay," play appropriately, and be accepting of children's presence. Positive reinforcement training is the most effective approach when it comes to training dogs the boundaries they must not cross.

In conclusion, Doberman Pinschers can make fantastic family dogs with the ideal training and socialization, but they need supervision around children. Most importantly, every Doberman Pinscher & Child interaction is unique, and not every dog is a good match for every child or family.


Greetings all,

I've owned a Doberman Pinscher as a guard dog, and in my opinion, they are exceptional guardians. They are renowned for their fierce loyalty to owners and want nothing more than to protect their family. Once trained, a Doberman would do anything in their power to keep their owners safe. These dogs are quite agile, fast on their feet and can intimidate anyone with their strength and imposing presence.

While I agree they're easy to train and willing to learn, it's crucial to note that Dobermans can be challenging to handle when dealing with certain situations. Owners must be firm, assertive, and patient to create a healthy relationship with them. Training should be intensive, continuous, and should start as early as eight weeks. Like any other breed of dog, starting early training will help them develop a sense of obedience and respect towards their owners.

In conclusion, I think Doberman Pinschers are great guard dogs given their protective instincts and loyalty towards their owners. However, it's important to socialize them, understand their temperament and behavior, have enough space for them, and invest quality time to train them to guarantee they are well-behaved guard dogs. In my opinion, they're rewarding dogs to own and a pleasure to have as a protector of the home.


Hey there,

I have owned a Doberman Pinscher for about five years now and I can definitely vouch for their abilities as guard dogs. My dog has an incredibly strong protective instinct and is always on alert when strangers approach our property. She takes her role as a protector very seriously and I feel much safer with her around.

In terms of training, I would say that Dobermans are relatively easy to train for protection work. They are intelligent and eager to please, so with the right training and socialization, they can become excellent guard dogs. I recommend starting with basic obedience training and gradually introducing protection exercises under the guidance of an experienced trainer.

One thing to keep in mind is that Dobermans can be very territorial, so it's important to socialize them properly from a young age to ensure that they don't become overly aggressive towards people or other animals. Overall, I would definitely recommend a Doberman Pinscher as a guard dog, but only to someone who is willing to put in the time and effort to properly train and socialize them.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community