Hi everyone,
I am new to the world of dog breeds and recently came across two breeds that have caught my interest - rottweilers and dobermans. While researching about these two breeds, I came across a claim that rottweilers originated from dobermans. I am confused about this statement as I thought they were two completely separate breeds.
Can any experienced dog owners or breeders shed some light on the origin of rottweilers and dobermans? Is there any truth to the claim that rottweilers came from dobermans? I would appreciate any insights or information you could provide me with. Thank you!

Hello everyone,
I've been a dog owner for many years now, and I have to say that Rottweilers and Dobermans are two of my favorite breeds. While it is true that they are different breeds with unique characteristics, they're both similar in some ways too. For example, they're both extremely intelligent, loyal, and loving dogs that require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation.
When it comes to exercise requirements, both Rottweilers and Dobermans are high-energy dogs that need at least an hour of exercise every day to stay healthy and happy. They also need plenty of toys and puzzles to keep their minds engaged, so make sure you're prepared to provide them with ample playtime.
One area where these breeds differ significantly is their guarding instincts. Rottweilers have been used as guard dogs for centuries and are known for their strong protective instincts towards their family, while Dobermans are more of a “watchdog” breed and tend to be more aloof towards strangers. While these traits can make them great guard dogs, it's essential to socialize them early and train them to differentiate friends from foe to prevent any aggressive behavior.
Ultimately, both Rottweilers and Dobermans can make great pets, depending on your lifestyle and needs. They do require consistent training, socialization, and plenty of love and attention to lead a happy and fulfilled life.