Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

If a Doberman and a Rottweiler were to fight, who do you think would win?

Hey guys, I'm new here and I've been thinking about getting a large dog breed as a pet for a long time now. While researching, I came across two breeds that caught my attention - Doberman and Rottweiler. Both of these breeds are known for their strength, aggression and loyalty. But I'm confused and can't decide which one to go for. So I thought I'd ask the experts here - if a Doberman and a Rottweiler were to fight, who do you think would win? I'm really curious to know your opinions and experience. Also, any advice on which breed would be a better fit for a novice dog owner like myself would be appreciated. Thank you!

All Replies


Hello friends, as a Rottweiler owner for several years now, I wanted to share my input on this thread regarding Rottweilers. I love my Rottie, and I have noticed several differences between Rottweilers and Dobermans. Firstly, Rottweilers are known for their strength and powerful build. While they are often referred to as "gentle giants," they can become formidable when they sense danger, meaning they are exceptional guard dogs.

One of the most significant differences between the two breeds is Rottweilers' calmer, more subdued nature. While they are still energetic dogs that require plenty of exercise and attention, Rottweilers tend to have a more laid-back temperament than Dobermans. My Rottie loves to lounge around the house and chew on bones just as much as she loves going for walks around the neighborhood.

Rottweilers are also known to bond quite intensely with their owners, and they are incredibly affectionate and loyal dogs. They are great with kids and make excellent family pets, and their calm demeanor means they can be suitable for anyone from families with children to retired individuals who want a loyal companion at their side.

Despite their friendly personality, Rottweilers do have a reputation for being intimidating dogs to strangers. This leads me to emphasize the importance of socialization and training from a young age for Rottweilers, just as it is for Dobermans. It turns them into balanced and well-mannered dogs while also keeping them physically healthy.

In conclusion, while both Rottweilers and Dobermans are excellent breeds, each breed has its unique traits. I believe it's all about what you desire from a dog breed and what their personality is like, so it is essential to research both breeds thoroughly before making a decision.


Hello everyone, as a dog enthusiast, it's a pleasure to join this conversation. I've had the opportunity to work with both Dobermans and Rottweilers as a dog trainer, and I understand that both breeds are popular for their athletic ability and fierce loyalty.

To answer the question, if a Doberman and a Rottweiler were to fight, it would be undoubtedly difficult to tell who would be the winner. Both breeds are physically capable of doing a lot of damage, and many factors, such as training and temperament, come into play. However, for me, the fight question is a bit redundant, as the goal in responsible pet ownership is never to encourage or incite animal fights.

It's always important to remember that pet ownership is a long-term responsibility that requires lots of love, time, and resources. It is vital to choose a breed that will complement your lifestyle and has the proper temperament for you and your family. As some of the other posters mentioned above, Dobermans are ideal for families that are active, while Rottweilers can be better suited to less active families.

No matter which breed you choose, it's always crucial to give them proper training, mental stimulation, exercise, and all the love they deserve. Both breeds are susceptible to specific health issues, so it's important to choose a reputable breeder that can give you a healthy pup.

In conclusion, both Dobermans and Rottweilers are excellent companion breeds but require a responsible pet owner to provide them with the best care possible. Choose a breed that is suited to your lifestyle and will work well with your family dynamics.


Hello everyone, as a dog behaviorist, I would like to add my thoughts to this conversation. I have worked with both Dobermans and Rottweilers, and each breed is unique in their way. While both breeds are extremely loyal and protective of their owners, they have different temperaments.

Firstly, Dobermans are intelligent, athletic, and sensitive dogs that crave individualized attention and exercise. They are fast learners and always eager to please their owners, but they can be high-strung if not properly trained and socialized from an early age.

On the other hand, Rottweilers are confident, calm, and docile dogs that are exceptionally loyal to their families. They are affectionate and tend to interact well with children but, like any large breeds, can be protective if they sense danger.

That being said, both breeds require a lot of physical and mental exercise, socialization, and love in their lives. Training should be consistent, firm but positive, and never harsh or heavy-handed. It is also essential to research the source of where you adopt your dog as well as breed-specific health issues.

Ultimately, any decision on choosing a dog breed should depend on your lifestyle and your overall comfort level with handling dogs. Both breeds have different characteristics, traits, and needs, and picking one should be based on your capacity, preferences, and time commitment to raising a happy, healthy dog. In general, puppies are often hard work but can mature into wonderful companions given the attention and nutrients they need.


Hello, everyone! As a long-time Doberman owner, I feel compelled to share my thoughts. First of all, both Dobermans and Rottweilers are excellent dogs that can make great companions to the right people. However, I opted for a Doberman largely because of their energy and athleticism, since I have an active lifestyle that allows me to take my dog for long walks or runs. Dobies have a reputation for being high-energy dogs that need plenty of exercise, meaning they constantly require supervision until trained to behave appropriately.

In terms of temperament, Dobies are known to be very devoted to their owners and protective of their families. They are typically quick learners and display high intelligence, which may make them challenging to keep intellectually stimulated without plenty of interactive play and physical exercise. While Dobermans may have a reputation for being intimidating, mine is as playful and goofy as any dog I've owned.

That being said, Dobermans can be challenging to train and can quickly become destructive if not given proper guidance and stimuli. It is essential to socialize them from an early stage and to consistently reinforce positive behaviors during puppyhood. Dobermans also have a range of health conditions, including bone diseases, that potential owners should be aware of.

Finally, it is crucial to note that owning any dog is a significant responsibility and that every dog's personality is different. While Dobermans make great companions, it's crucial to pick a breed that resonates with your lifestyle and your family to ensure a happy, healthy home life. So, if you're looking for a dog that is enthusiastic, intelligent, and energetic, a Doberman might be the right breed for you.


Hi there, as someone who has had a Rottweiler for years now, I can tell you that they make fantastic pets! My Rottie is incredibly loyal, obedient, and friendly - with both adults and kids. Although I've never owned a Doberman, I agree that both breeds are tough, muscular and have a history and reputation of being great guard dogs.

However, it is essential to note that each breed has its own unique personality and temperament. Rottweilers are known to be one of the most loyal and protective dogs. They're known for their courage and bravery, always ready to defend their territory or family. They're also extremely intelligent, which means they're quick learners and can be easily trained to follow commands.

Also, Rottweilers are often much bigger in size and weight than Dobermans, which may make them a better fit for anyone looking for a larger dog breed. However, this also means that they will require more food, exercise and space compared to a smaller Doberman.

In conclusion, I would suggest you go with a Rottweiler if you're looking for a loyal and affectionate pet that can also act as a great guard dog. They are a larger dog breed, but they're often docile in temperament unless provoked. Ultimately, the deciding factor should be what size and personality fit best with your lifestyle and living conditions.


Hello everyone, as someone who has owned both a Rottweiler and a Doberman, I wanted to share my experience with both breeds. I initially owned a Doberman and was very impressed with their athleticism, energy, and intelligence. However, as much as I loved my Doberman, I found that their high strung temperament sometimes made it difficult to control them, especially when overwhelmed.

Eventually, I adopted a Rottweiler, and I can say that their ease of handling and calm nature was a breath of fresh air. Rottweilers are more laid-back, less demanding of attention, and easier to train, making them more ideal for first-time dog owners. If Dobermans need lots of physical exercise, Rottweilers are more mentally stimulated, so puzzles and games can be very helpful in keeping them active.

Additionally, Rottweilers are great companions for families with children of all ages. They are incredibly protective of their loved ones, and their calm demeanor makes them a favorite amongst animal charities, often referred to as "nannies" for how well they take care of kids (and adults, too).

It's important to remember that both breeds require plenty of early socialization and obedience training, especially Rottweilers, as they can be distrusting of strangers if not sufficiently socialized. Also, provide your Rottweiler with plenty of stimulating toys, chew toys or chews, digging spots, and designated areas to rest that will keep them challenged and engaged.

In conclusion, it boils down to what you can give and expect of a dog breed. While both breeds have their pros and cons, I'd recommend the Rottweiler for anyone looking for a family companion that is loyal, protective and a little bit more relaxed in their personality.


Hey there! I have owned both Dobermans and Rottweilers in the past, and from my experience, both breeds are incredibly loyal and make great pets. However, when it comes to a hypothetical fight between the two, I think it would be a pretty even match. Both breeds are muscular and aggressive, so it could go either way.

However, I want to emphasize that choosing a dog should not be based on their fighting abilities. It's important to choose a breed that suits your lifestyle and personality. Both Dobermans and Rottweilers require a lot of exercise and training, so as a novice dog owner, you need to be prepared to put in the effort to provide them with the appropriate care and attention they need.

Moreover, it's essential to note that Rottweilers are known to be more calm and laidback than Dobermans. And Dobie can be a bit more energetic and high-strung compared to Rottie. So, if you're looking for a more relaxed and affectionate dog with a good temperament, then Rottweiler breed may be a better fit.

Ultimately, both breeds have their pros and cons, and they can both make excellent pets. It all comes down to your lifestyle, home environment, and what you desire from a furry companion. Good luck with your decision-making process!


Hey there, as someone who has had both a Doberman and a Rottweiler as family pets, I can tell you that both breeds are exceptional, but they do have their differences.

Dobermans are known for being high-energy and require lots of attention and exercise. They're smaller in size and are incredibly athletic, which means they're great for families that are always on the move. In contrast, Rottweilers, as mentioned before, are larger in size and may require more space or exercise than a Doberman. They're generally calmer and more laid back, which may make them better suited for those who are looking for an affectionate companion that also doubles up as a guard dog.

In terms of loyalty, I found that both breeds are incredibly devoted to their owners and get along well with children. However, it's important to note that both breeds require a lot of time and patience when it comes to training them. They can be stubborn at times and may cause trouble if not properly trained or disciplined.

In regards to the hypothetical fight between the two breeds mentioned earlier, I believe that it would be a tough match as both breeds are known to be incredibly powerful and quick. It's impossible to say who would win as it would depend on a multitude of factors such as age, size, and personality.

Ultimately, the most important factor to consider when choosing between a Doberman and a Rottweiler is your lifestyle and living environment. If you're an active person and live in an apartment or smaller house, a Doberman may be a better choice for you. However, if you're willing to put in more care, time and space, then a Rottweiler may be just what you need.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community