Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:
63
Q:

If pit bulls are so vicious why don't they train them as police attack dogs?

Hey guys, I have been hearing a lot of mixed things about pit bulls and their aggression. Some people say they are naturally aggressive and dangerous, while others claim they are sweet and loyal pets. I am confused about why people are so scared of pit bulls when they can be trained as police attack dogs. If these dogs are capable of such intense training, why can't they be trusted as pets? Is aggression really that ingrained in their nature, or is it about how they are raised and trained? I would love to hear from people who have experience with pit bulls or with training attack dogs in general. Thanks!

All Replies

lhammes

Hey there, I have never trained a pit bull or any attack dogs for that matter, but I have worked with animals in rescue and rehabilitation settings. I agree with the previous comments that each dog should be evaluated on an individual basis rather than being judged solely based on their breed. The temperament and training of each dog play an important role in their behavior.

However, it is also important to note that some breeds have been selectively bred for specific traits that make them more suitable for certain tasks than others. For instance, a pit bull's physique and powerful jaw may make them more suited for tasks that require physical strength, such as search-and-rescue work. On the other hand, breeds like German Shepherds and Belgian Malinois have been bred for their working ability and intelligence, which may make them better suited for law enforcement work.

In the end, the suitability of a dog for police work depends on many factors, including breed, training, and individual temperament. While certain breeds may be more commonly used for police work for specific reasons, it is important to also evaluate individual dogs based on their unique skill set and personality. Ultimately, any dog, regardless of breed, can be a great companion or working animal if they are given proper care, training, and attention.

maritza.hessel

Hi there, I used to work as a police dog trainer and I have to say that not all dog breeds are suitable for police work, including pit bulls. While pit bulls may be smart and trainable, they are not bred for the specific tasks that police dogs are trained for. For example, German Shepherds and Belgian Malinois are chosen for their innate abilities to detect scents, track suspects, and perform obedience training. These breeds have been selectively bred for work with the police and military for many generations. Pit bulls, on the other hand, were originally bred as fighting dogs, so their focus and attention is on aggression, not on hearing commands from humans. There are some organizations that train pit bulls for specialized tasks like drug detection or search and rescue, but it's not a common practice because there are other breeds that are better suited for these roles. So to answer your question, just because a dog is trainable doesn't mean it is suitable for every kind of work.

nickolas91

Hey there, I have owned a pit bull for the past 5 years and she is the most loving and friendly dog I have ever had. I think the perception of pit bulls as vicious comes from a combination of media sensationalism and a few isolated incidents of attacks. That being said, it is true that pit bulls are powerful animals and they need to be trained and socialized properly. I do think they can be great candidates for police or military training, but not all pit bulls have the temperament or physical ability for that kind of work. Just like any other breed, they each have their own personalities and strengths. I have seen firsthand how smart and trainable my pit bull is, but I also know that she wouldn't be able to handle the physical demands of a police dog. So I think it's important to evaluate each dog on an individual basis and not make sweeping generalizations about pit bulls as a whole.

bfay

Hello everyone, I have never owned a pit bull nor trained one as a police dog, but I have been studying animal behavior for many years. In my opinion, the question of whether pit bulls can be trained as police attack dogs is not about the breed itself, but about the individual dog's temperament, drive, and natural abilities. While there are certainly breeds that are better suited for police work than others, it's unfair to completely stereotype any breed as being incapable of such work. Pit bulls, like any other breed, can be trained to do almost anything if they have the right skills and motivation.

That being said, I do believe that the reputation surrounding pit bulls' aggression is largely based on misconceptions and stereotypes. The media often portrays them as aggressive and dangerous, which can cause people to be scared of them. However, the reality is that pit bulls are not naturally aggressive towards humans, and are actually very loyal and loving pets when they are raised and trained properly. In conclusion, while pit bulls may not be the best choice for police attack dogs, it's important to remember that each dog must be evaluated individually and not based on stereotypes associated with their breed.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community