Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Is a Doberman one of the best protection dogs?

Hi all,

I've been considering getting a protection dog for my home and family, and I'm wondering if a Doberman would be a good choice. I've heard that they are very protective and loyal, but I wanted to get some opinions from those who have experience with Dobermans or other similar breeds.

I live in a suburban area and have a decently sized yard, but I also have neighbors nearby. I want a dog that can deter potential intruders and protect my family if necessary. I have two young children, so I also want a dog that is good with kids and won't be overly aggressive.

Do you think a Doberman would be a good fit for my situation? Are there any other breeds that you would recommend? Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

All Replies


Hello everyone,

I have owned Dobermans for many years, and I can attest to their excellent protective instinct. They are very versatile and can perform various tasks, such as acting as a service dog, therapy dog, or search and rescue dog.

While Dobermans need adequate socialization and training, they are inherently loyal and protective, making them ideal candidates for guarding homes and families. Their muscular frame, alertness, and courageous attitude make them an impressive sight to behold.

However, as with any breed, Dobermans are not a one-size-fits-all solution for everyone. They require plenty of physical activity and mental stimulation to channel their energy in a positive direction. Choosing a Doberman should depend on your ability to handle their high energy levels and train them.

Moreover, Dobermans, like all dogs, require a loving and supportive environment to thrive. They are incredibly intelligent and sensitive, and unkind treatment will break their spirit.

Some other viable options include German Shepherds, Belgian Malinois, Rottweilers, and Akitas, among others. Ultimately, the key is to choose a dog that suits your personality, lifestyle, and living conditions.

In summary, Dobermans are excellent protection dogs, but they require significant socialization, training, and exercise to thrive in your home. With the proper care and devotion, they can make loyal and protective companions for you and your family.


Hi everyone,

I have owned a Doberman Pinscher for about ten years now, and I must say that they are great protection dogs. Not only are they loyal and dedicated, but they are also very alert and can sense danger from miles away.

However, it's worth keeping in mind that Dobermans have the potential to be aggressive if they are not socialized properly. They are naturally protective, so it's essential to train them from a young age to differentiate between potential threats and regular visitors. Consistent training can also help them develop good socialization skills and prevent them from becoming overly aggressive.

When it comes to children, Dobermans can be great companions, provided that they are trained and socialized properly. My Doberman has always been very gentle and patient with my children and has always made sure to keep them out of harm's way.

In terms of what other breeds to consider, I would recommend German Shepherds, Belgian Malinois, or Boxers as they also make great protection dogs. However, choosing a dog breed that suits your lifestyle and living conditions is crucial.

In conclusion, Dobermans are excellent protection dogs and can be great companions, but they require patience, consistency, and proper socialization. With the right training, they can provide your family with safety and security, and be a loyal member of the family.


Hi there,

I have firsthand experience with Dobermans, and I have to say that they are fantastic protection dogs. My Doberman, Max, has been a loyal companion and protector for my family for years. He is extremely alert and constantly aware of his surroundings, which makes him an excellent watch dog.

However, I will say that Dobermans can be quite high-strung and require a lot of exercise and training. They are very intelligent, but also very strong-willed, so it's important to establish yourself as the alpha and provide consistent training and structure.

In terms of their demeanor with children, I have found that Dobermans can be very gentle and patient. Max loves my young nieces and nephews and is always very gentle with them. However, it's important to supervise interactions with any large dog and teach children how to properly behave around them.

Overall, I would definitely recommend a Doberman as a protection dog, but make sure you are prepared to put in the time and effort to properly train and socialize them. There are other breeds that could also be good options, such as German Shepherds or Rottweilers, but ultimately it comes down to personal preference and individual dog temperament.


Hello everyone,

Having owned a Doberman for a couple of years, I would definitely recommend them as great protection dogs. These dogs are very loyal, devoted, and will stop at nothing to protect their owners. They are very intelligent, easily trainable, and have an intimidating presence that can make any potential intruder think twice.

However, like previous users have mentioned, Dobermans require a lot of training, socialization, and exercise. These dogs are high-energy and love to be active, so it's important to give them enough mental and physical stimulation. Also, I would like to add that Dobermans can be quite stubborn at times, so consistent and patient training is necessary.

As for their behavior with children, from my experience, they are generally good with kids, but like with any other dog, it's essential to supervise them when playing together and teach children how to interact with dogs properly.

In conclusion, I would definitely recommend a Doberman as an excellent protection dog, but keep in mind that they require a responsible owner who is willing to invest time, effort, and money to provide for them. If you are looking for other breeds, I'd suggest considering German Shepherds or Belgian Malinois, but ultimately, it mostly comes down to individual personality and lifestyle.


Hey everyone,

I've had experience with Dobermans and other protection dog breeds, and I think that Dobermans are great protection dogs. They're incredibly intelligent, loyal, and protective by nature, making them ideal for guarding families and homes.

Training is essential when it comes to owning a Doberman. They need clear guidelines and structure to understand their boundaries and the behaviors expected of them. Positive reinforcement works brilliantly with Dobermans, and with the correct directions, they adapt to new environments and forms strong bonds with their owners.

One thing to keep in mind is that Dobermans require substantial daily exercise and tend to become bored and destructive if they lack it. They need an outlet for their energies and enjoy activities such as running, hiking, obedience training, and playing fetch.

When it comes to children, Dobermans can be affectionate and gentle. However, it's crucial to supervise their interactions and teach children how to treat dogs respectfully. Dobermans are strong and robust, and even unintentional play can end in accidents.

Other breeds that make excellent protection dogs include German Shepherds, Rottweilers, Great Danes, and Boxers. But at the end of the day, finding the right protection dog is all about finding one that suits your needs and lifestyle.

In conclusion, Dobermans are undoubtedly a great choice for a protection dog with a strong sense of loyalty and defensive instincts. They require firm, positive reinforcement training and adequate exercise but can be incredibly loving companions.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community