Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Is a Doberman Pinscher a good choice as a family pet over a German Shepherd or a Labrador ?

Hi everyone,

I've been doing some research on different dog breeds and I'm wondering if a Doberman Pinscher would make a good family pet compared to a German Shepherd or a Labrador. My family and I are looking for a dog that is loyal, playful, and protective but also good with children. We have two young kids aged 5 and 7, so it's important that the dog is gentle around them.

I've read that Doberman Pinschers are intelligent and loyal dogs, but can also be stubborn and require a lot of training. German Shepherds are known for their protective instincts and obedience, but can be wary of strangers. And Labradors are often considered one of the best family pets due to their friendly and outgoing nature, but can also be prone to excitement and jumping.

I would love to hear from anyone who has experience with any of these breeds or has any advice on which one would be the best fit for our family. Thank you in advance for any help or suggestions!

All Replies


Hi there!

I personally have a Doberman Pinscher and I have to say, she has been an amazing addition to my family. She is extremely loyal and protective, which makes me feel safe and secure in my home. She also loves to play and is very gentle with my young son.

I will say, however, that Dobermans require a lot of training and socialization. They can be stubborn at times, but with consistent training, they can be well-behaved and obedient. So if you're willing to put in the time and effort, then a Doberman could be a great family pet.

I have also had experience with a German Shepherd, and while they are also very loyal and protective, they can be a bit more aggressive towards strangers. They also require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation, so be prepared for an active dog if you decide on a German Shepherd.

I don't have personal experience with Labradors, but I have heard that they make great family pets due to their friendly and outgoing nature. They are usually great with children, but like any dog, require proper training and socialization.

Ultimately, it comes down to what you are looking for in a family pet and what you are willing to commit to in terms of training and care. I hope this helps in your decision-making process!


Hello there!

We have had a German Shepherd for the last 10 years, and she's been a wonderful pet for our family. She has always been loyal and protective, making us feel safe and secure in our home. She's also incredibly intelligent, which made it easy for us to train and socialize her.

However, one of the downsides of having a German Shepherd is that they can be wary of strangers. It takes a while for them to warm up to new people, which could make socializing them a bit of a challenge. They also require a lot of exercise, both physical and online. German Shepherds have a lot of energy, so it's essential to keep them mentally stimulated as well.

Compared to Labradors, I would say that German Shepherds are more protective and make better watchdogs. They are bred for guarding and protection, and they excel at it. Having said that, my friend has a Labrador, and even though he's not as protective as our German Shepherd, he is an excellent family pet. He is friendly, outgoing, and great with kids. He is incredibly loyal, and his personality is infectious.

Overall, I think German Shepherds can make great family pets, but they require a lot of work and attention. If you're willing to put in the time and effort, they can be an amazing addition to your family. On the other hand, If you're looking for a more outgoing, friendly dog, then a Labrador could be the right choice for you.


Hi there!

I have had a Labrador for several years now, and personally, I think they make the best family pets. They are known for their friendly and outgoing nature and are great with children. They have a good temperament, which makes them easy to train and a joy to be around. My lab immediately became best friends with my children and is always up for playtime, walks, and snuggles.

However, one thing to keep in mind is that labs can have a tendency to become overweight if not properly exercised, so it is essential to have a consistent exercise routine for them. They also have a lot of energy, so be prepared to provide them with plenty of playtime and walks.

When it comes to comparing against Doberman Pinschers, they are also loyal dogs and can be great family pets, but they require a higher level of training and socialization. They need firm and consistent training, which can be time-consuming, especially for busy families. German Shepherds can also be good family pets, but they can be wary of strangers and need a lot of exercise.

In conclusion, while Doberman Pinschers and German Shepherds can make loyal pets, Labradors are well known for their friendly and outgoing nature, which makes them great family pets.


Hello everyone!

I have had experience with a Doberman Pinscher and a Labrador, and I can say that both breeds have their own unique qualities when it comes to being a family pet.

In terms of Doberman Pinschers, they are incredibly loyal and protective, which makes them a great guard dog for your family. They are also super intelligent and can easily be trained to perform tasks with ease. However, they have a bit of a stubborn streak, so they require a firm hand when it comes to training.

As for Labradors, they are friendly, outgoing, and have an easy-going nature, which makes them an ideal family pet. They are great with kids and make excellent companions for the whole family. It's also great that they are sociable, so they can quickly adapt to your family's daily activities.

Overall, both breeds have their pros and cons, and it ultimately depends on the family's preference when it comes to selecting a pet. Dobermans are known for their protective nature, while Labradors are known for their amiable disposition. If you're looking for a loyal and fiercely protective dog, then maybe go for the Doberman, and if you're looking for an easy-going family companion, you could opt for a Labrador.


Hi everyone!

I am a proud owner of a German Shepherd, and I can tell you that they make fantastic family pets! They are highly intelligent, loyal, and protective, which makes them great guard dogs for your family. My German Shepherd has been a great protector and companion for my family, and she is always eager to play and go on walks with us.

However, like many of the other breeds mentioned, German Shepherds are a high-energy breed and need lots of exercise to stay healthy and happy. They also require a lot of mental stimulation, both through training and playtime, so it is crucial to have a plan for keeping them occupied. Socialization is also key, as they can be a bit standoffish with strangers if not properly introduced.

In comparison to Labradors and Dobermans, I would say that German Shepherds have a more serious and focused demeanor. They are excellent at picking up on cues and have a natural desire to protect their families, which can be comforting in dangerous situations. However, this also means that they require more attention and training than some other breeds.

Therefore, while German Shepherds make great family pets, they may be better suited for families with experience in pet ownership or those willing to commit time and energy towards their training and care.


Hey there!

Based on my personal experience, I think Labradors make the best family pets. They have a friendly disposition, making them great with kids and other pets. They are also highly trainable, and you can teach them various tricks and commands with ease.

One of the best things about Labradors is that they can adapt to different types of households. They are content with a small apartment or a big yard, as long as they get their regular exercise. Additionally, they are great with people who have allergies, as they shed very little compared to other dog breeds.

Now, in terms of Dobermans and German Shepherds, I personally feel that they are better suited to more experienced owners. These breeds have specific needs regarding training, exercise, and socialization, which can prove overwhelming for a first-time pet owner.

However, that's not to say that these breeds don't make great pets. Dobermans and German Shepherds are loyal and intelligent, making them excellent guard dogs. They are also highly trainable, but it requires more time and effort to train them compared to Labradors.

In conclusion, I believe that Labradors are the best family pets. They are friendly, easy-going, and adaptable to different types of households. Nonetheless, Doberman Pinschers and German Shepherds could be great pets for experienced owners who are willing to put in time and effort into their training and socialization.


Hello there!

I have had both a German Shepherd and a Labrador, and they each had their own unique qualities that made them great family pets.

In terms of my German Shepherd, he was incredibly protective and loyal to my family. He acted like a watchdog and would bark at any suspicious sights or sounds in and around the house. However, this trait could also be a bit of a downside as he tended to growl and bark at strangers, even when we had visitors. As a result, it was important for us to be cautious when introducing him to new people. He required a lot of exercise and playtime, but if you give him enough attention and moderate exercise, they are perfect dogs for families.

My Labrador, on the other hand, was the friendliest dog you'd ever meet. She was incredibly outgoing and playful, and would always be eager to make new friends, including other dogs. She was also very gentle with children and a great companion to my kids. However, because of her nature, she was easily excitable, and we had to train her to calm down at times. Another aspect to consider is their shedding, so it's essential to be prepared for some grooming and training techniques.

Ultimately, it depends on what you are looking for in a dog. German Shepherds and Doberman Pinschers can provide a sense of protection and loyalty, but they can also be more challenging dogs to train and socialize. Labradors, on the other hand, are known for their friendly and playful personalities, but they require some efforts in training their behavior. It's best to research each breed and consider your family's lifestyle before selecting one.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community