Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:
89
Q:

Rottie vs Doberman vs GSD, which one is best for me?

Hi everyone,

I am looking for some advice in choosing between a Rottweiler, Doberman, and German Shepherd Dog (GSD). I have been thinking about getting a larger breed dog as a companion and a family pet. I want a dog that can provide protection to my family and home, as well as being a loyal and playful companion.

I have read up on these breeds and know that they all have their unique qualities and traits. However, I am having a hard time deciding on which one would be best for me and my family. I have young children, so safety and temperament are very important factors to me.

While I am leaning towards a GSD, I have heard great things about Rottweilers and Dobermans as well. I also know that each breed requires different amounts of exercise and attention, so that is something to consider as well.

If anyone has any personal experiences or insights on these breeds, I would really appreciate your input. Thank you in advance!

All Replies

dickinson.tia

Hi there,

I have owned both a Rottweiler and a Doberman in the past and I have to say that they were both great dogs. However, considering you have young children, I would recommend going with a GSD.

My Rottweiler was a great family dog, very loyal and protective. However, she was a bit stubborn and required a lot of attention and training. My Doberman, on the other hand, was extremely energetic and playful. He was also very protective, but sometimes a bit too aggressive towards strangers.

In my experience, GSDs are very intelligent, loyal, and easy to train. They make great family dogs and are very protective of their owners. They are also very playful and love to run around and play fetch.

One thing to keep in mind is that GSDs require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation. They are a working breed and need to be kept busy to stay happy and healthy. If you have the time and energy to provide them with the exercise and attention they need, a GSD would be a great choice for you.

Hope this helps!

feeney.brenda

Hello everyone,

I have experience with German Shepherds and I can say that they make excellent family pets. They are incredibly intelligent, loyal, and protective of their family. They tend to be very patient with children and are playful and energetic, which makes them great companions.

One thing that sets the German Shepherd apart from other breeds is their versatility. They have been bred for various jobs such as police work, search and rescue, and therapy dogs. This means that they are highly trainable and can adapt to various living situations with ease.

German Shepherds are also very easy to groom since their coats are short and easy to manage. They do shed quite a bit, but with regular grooming, it's easy to keep their shedding under control.

It is important to note that like most large breeds, German Shepherds require plenty of exercise to remain healthy and happy. They love to run and play and need plenty of space to do so. It is also important to ensure that your German Shepherd is properly socialized from a young age to prevent aggression towards strangers.

In conclusion, I highly recommend German Shepherds as a family pet. They are intelligent, loyal, and protective, and their versatility makes them adaptable to various living situations. They are great companions for children, and with proper training and care, they make excellent family pets.

vbrakus

Hey,

I had a Rottweiler when I was growing up, and he was an amazing dog. He was loyal, protective, and made the perfect playmate for me and my siblings. He had a gentle nature and was patient even when we were being rambunctious kids.

Rottweilers are very confident and courageous dogs. They have an innate desire to protect their family, and they are known for their loyalty and affectionate nature towards their owners. They also have a reputation for being great family dogs as they bond well with children and are patient with them.

However, Rottweilers are considered a high maintenance breed when it comes to grooming. They shed quite a bit and require regular grooming to keep their coats shiny and healthy. They also require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation to remain active and healthy.

In my opinion, Rottweilers are great family pets, but it is important to train and socialize them from a young age so that they know how to behave around strangers. They can be slow to warm up to new people, and if not trained well, can be aggressive towards strangers.

In conclusion, while I don't have experience with Dobermans or GSDs, I can definitely say that Rottweilers are a great choice for a family with children. They are loyal, protective, and patient. When properly trained and socialized, they can make great pets that are loved by everyone in the family.

brekke.freddie

Hello there,

I have personal experience with owning a German Shepherd, Rottweiler, and Doberman. All three breeds have their own set of unique characteristics, but when it comes to a family with young children, I would recommend a German Shepherd.

German Shepherds are loyal, intelligent, and great protectors of their family. They are easy to train and make great family pets. They are patient with children, playful and energetic, which makes them great companions for kids. In addition, they are very adaptable and can adjust well to various living situations.

My Rottweiler was also a great family pet, but she did have a tendency to be stubborn, which made training a bit of a challenge. She was affectionate and protective, but sometimes, her powerful presence could intimidate young children. Dobermans can be a bit too hyperactive for young children, and they require a lot of training and socialization to be properly integrated into a family.

One thing to note is that German Shepherds do shed a lot, so it is important to groom and brush them regularly. Also, they require plenty of exercise and mental stimulation to stay healthy and happy.

In summary, all three breeds are great options, but if you are looking for a family dog that does well with young children, German Shepherds are an excellent choice. They are loyal, intelligent, and protective, making them great companions for children.

mlindgren

Hello everyone,

I have had experience with Dobermans and Rottweilers in the past and I have to say that both breeds make great family pets. However, considering that you have young children, I would lean towards a Rottweiler.

Rottweilers are known for their loyalty and protective nature, making them great family dogs. In my experience, they can be very affectionate towards their families, and also very gentle with children. They are generally easy to train, and similar to GSDs, they need plenty of exercise to remain healthy and happy.

One of the downsides of owning a Rottie is their shedding problem. They do shed quite a bit, especially during the shedding season. However, with regular grooming and brushing, this can be managed efficiently.

On the other hand, Dobermans are known for their high energy and playful nature. They require plenty of attention, exercise, and mental stimulation to keep their behavior in check. They can be great companions for children, but require careful training to minimize aggressive behavior towards strangers.

In conclusion, all three breeds are great choices, but for families with young children, I would suggest a Rottweiler. They are loyal, protective and affectionate as well as relatively easy to train. However, it is important to choose a reputable breeder when choosing a dog of any breed.

ikrajcik

Hello everyone,

I am a proud owner of a Doberman, and I have to say that they are amazing family pets. While they may not be the first breed that comes to mind when thinking about a family dog, they can be great companions for children.

Dobermans are very intelligent, loyal, and protective dogs. They are energetic and playful, which makes them great playmates for kids. They are also very protective and watchful of their human family, which will give you peace of mind when it comes to safety. However, I do agree that they need careful training and socialization to avoid aggressive behavior towards strangers.

One thing to keep in mind is that Dobermans require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation to stay healthy and happy. They need plenty of space to run and play, so if you live in a small apartment or don't have a backyard, this might not be the best breed for you.

In conclusion, while the Rottweiler and German Shepherd are also great family pets, Dobermans should not be overlooked. They are loving, loyal, and great with children, but require careful training and socialization to avoid any issues. If you have the time and space to provide them with the exercise and attention they need, a Doberman would make a great addition to any family.

buddy57

Hey there,

I have experience with German Shepherds and I have to say that they are amazing family dogs. They are loyal, protective and intelligent creatures that can easily adapt to various situations. They make great playmates for children as well, due to their high energy and loving nature.

I had a GSD for 12 years, and she was a wonderful addition to our family. She was very obedient and easy to train. We taught her basic commands like sit, stay, and come, and she learned them very quickly. She was also very protective of us and would bark at strangers. This made us feel safe whenever we were alone at home.

German Shepherds have a great sense of smell, which makes them great working dogs. They can be trained to do various tasks such as search and rescue, detection of drugs, and protection. However, one disadvantage of owning a GSD is their shedding. They tend to shed a lot, especially during the spring and fall seasons.

Overall, I would highly recommend a German Shepherd as a family pet. They are loving, loyal, intelligent, and protective creatures that quickly adapt to various situations.

jackie.stanton

Hi there,

I have owned all three breeds in the past, and each one has its own unique qualities. However, if you have young children, I would strongly recommend going with a German Shepherd.

German Shepherds are excellent with children and can be very protective of them. They are intelligent and easy to train, making them great family dogs. Also, GSD's are generally more social with other people and animals than Rottweilers and Dobermans.

I have found that Rottweilers and Dobermans can be more aggressive towards strangers, and this can pose a safety risk around young children. Both breeds require extensive training to be properly socialized and make great family pets.

In terms of exercise, all three breeds are high energy and require plenty of exercise. However, GSD's are a working breed and are accustomed to regular exercise and mental stimulation. They love to run, play fetch, and participate in agility courses.

One thing to keep in mind when choosing a GSD is their potential health problems. They are prone to certain genetic disorders such as hip dysplasia, so it's important to choose a reputable breeder who has tested their dogs for these disorders.

Overall, I would recommend a German Shepherd for a family with young children. They are intelligent, loyal, and great with kids. With proper training and socialization, they make wonderful pets.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community