Should I buy a Doberman or a GSD as a guard dog?

Hello everyone,

I have personally owned a GSD and a Doberman as guard dogs, and I would say that both breeds have their strengths and weaknesses.

In terms of guard dog abilities, GSDs have a more intimidating and aggressive presence, while Dobermans have a more alert and watchful demeanor. Both breeds are intelligent and trainable, but in my experience, GSDs can have a higher tolerance for pain and a stronger bite force.

When it comes to training, I found that my Doberman was easier to train and more eager to please than my GSD. However, my GSD was more loyal and protective of our home and family.

In terms of cost of ownership, both breeds can be expensive due to their high energy levels and health issues. GSDs are prone to hip dysplasia, and Dobermans can be prone to heart issues, which can add to the cost of ownership.

Overall, both breeds can make excellent guard dogs, and the decision ultimately comes down to personal preference and the individual dog's personality. I would recommend meeting several dogs of each breed and consulting with a breeder or trainer to determine which breed may be the best fit for your specific needs.

Best of luck in your search for the perfect guard dog!

Hello all,

I have owned both a GSD and a Doberman, and I have to say that both breeds can make great guard dogs, but ultimately it comes down to the individual dog and their personality.

In general, GSDs tend to be more territorial and protective of their owners and home, while Dobermans have a more independent nature and may act as more of a deterrent to intruders.

When it comes to training, both breeds require consistent socialization and obedience training to be effective guard dogs. I would say that Dobermans tend to be more responsive to training, as they crave attention and affection from their owners, whereas GSDs can be more stubborn and strong-willed.

In terms of cost of ownership, both breeds can be expensive, especially if you go through a reputable breeder. Dobermans can be prone to certain health issues, as another user mentioned, which can add to the cost of ownership.

Ultimately, I believe that the decision comes down to personal preference and the individual dog's temperament. You may want to consider meeting several dogs of each breed and consulting with a breeder or trainer to determine which breed may be the best fit for you and your family.

Good luck with your decision!

Hello there,

As a former GSD owner, I would recommend this breed for guard dog purposes. In my experience, GSDs are incredibly loyal, intelligent, and trainable dogs. They have a natural protective instinct and are very good at assessing potentially dangerous situations.

When it comes to training, GSDs definitely require a lot of socialization and consistency. They can be strong-willed, but with proper training and positive reinforcement, they are more than capable of becoming a well-trained guard dog.

In terms of cost of ownership, GSDs can also be expensive, especially if you go through a reputable breeder. They do tend to have some health issues such as hip dysplasia or arthritis, which can require regular vet checkups and medications.

Overall, I believe that GSDs make excellent guard dogs due to their protective instinct, intelligence, and loyalty. However, I would recommend doing thorough research on both breeds and consulting with a breeder or trainer before making a final decision.

Best of luck to you!

Hi there,

I've had experience with both Dobermans and GSDs as guard dogs, and it really depends on what you're looking for in a guard dog. In my experience, GSDs tend to be more territorial and protective of their owners and property, whereas Dobermans have a more aloof disposition but are extremely loyal to their owners.

In terms of ease of training, I've found Dobermans to be more trainable than GSDs, as they tend to be more eager to please their owners. However, both breeds require consistent and structured training to be effective guard dogs.

In terms of cost of ownership, both breeds can be expensive, as they require high-quality food, regular veterinary care, and training. However, owning a Doberman may be slightly more expensive as they can be prone to certain health issues such as hip dysplasia and dilated cardiomyopathy.

Overall, I think either breed could make a great guard dog, but it really depends on your individual needs and preferences. I would recommend researching both breeds thoroughly and consulting with a reputable breeder or trainer before making a decision.

Good luck with your search!

More Topics Related to Doberman

• Is A Doberman a good family dog?
• Is Doberman a loyal dog?
• Do Dobermans bark a lot?
• Are Dobermans hard to train?
• How are Doberman dogs as pets?

More Topics Related to Loyal

• Should I get a Doberman Pinscher?
• Why are Doberman dogs so rare these days?
• What's a better family dog, Doberman or Rottweiler?
• How I differentiate between doberman and rottweiler breed?
• Is a Doberman one of the best protection dogs?

More Topics Related to Aggressive

• Are Doberman dogs kid-friendly?
• How do I know if a Doberman Pinscher is right for me and my family?
• How/Why/When did Doberman Pinschers get their 'bad' reputation?
• Is it possible to tame a Doberman?
• Why should you not get a Doberman?