Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:
76
Q:

What makes a better personal/property protection dog, a Doberman or a Belgian Malinois?

I am considering getting a personal/property protection dog, and I've narrowed it down to two breeds that I really like - a Doberman and a Belgian Malinois. However, I'm having a hard time deciding which one would make a better protection dog. My main priorities are a dog that is loyal, highly trainable, and will effectively protect me and my property when necessary. I also want a dog that is good with children and other pets, as I have a family and several other animals at home. So, can anyone share their experiences or knowledge about these two breeds and help me make an informed decision?

All Replies

dubuque.alden

I've owned both a Doberman and a Belgian Malinois as personal and property protection dogs, and both breeds have their own strengths and weaknesses. However, in my personal experience, the Belgian Malinois is the better option for a protection dog.

Belgian Malinois are highly intelligent and can learn commands and skills quickly. They are also fiercely loyal to their owners and will do anything to protect them. Additionally, Belgian Malinois are known for their high energy levels and incredible strength and agility, making them an excellent choice for those looking for a powerful protector.

While Dobermans are also intelligent, loyal, and trainable, I've found that they tend to be more anxious and sensitive. They may not handle being away from their owners for extended periods of time or living in a high-stress environment as well as a Belgian Malinois might.

However, it's important to note that both breeds require a lot of work, training, socialization, and proper care to be good protection dogs. It's essential to do thorough research and consult with experienced trainers before deciding on a protection dog, as these dogs require a lot of commitment and investment from their owners.

fahey.royal

I have trained and worked with both Dobermans and Belgian Malinois as personal and property protection dogs, and I have to say that it really depends on what you're looking for in a dog. Both breeds are highly intelligent, trainable, and fiercely loyal to their owners. However, there are a few differences between the two breeds that may sway your decision.

Dobermans are known for their loyalty to their owners and their willingness to please, which makes them easy to train and an excellent choice for families with children. They are natural protectors and will often assume the role of a watchdog without being taught. On the other hand, Belgian Malinois have a strong prey drive and are more suited for experienced owners who are willing to invest time and effort in training them. They make excellent working dogs and are often used in law enforcement and military operations due to their exceptional strength and agility.

Ultimately, both breeds can make excellent personal and property protection dogs, but it really depends on your individual circumstances and what you're looking for in a dog. I recommend doing thorough research and consulting with experienced trainers to make an informed decision.

julien.halvorson

I have a Belgian Malinois as my personal and property protection dog, and I couldn't be happier with my choice. My dog is smart, energetic, and always ready to protect me and my property. He is highly trainable and can pick up new commands and skills quickly.

While the Belgian Malinois breed can be a bit more challenging to handle than some other breeds, with the proper training and socialization, they can make amazing protection dogs. They are incredibly loyal to their owners and have an intense desire to please them.

That being said, before getting a Belgian Malinois or any breed as a protection dog, it's important to evaluate your lifestyle and make sure you have enough time and resources to properly train and care for your dog. These dogs require a lot of physical and mental stimulation, and they need to be properly exercised and socialized to ensure they don't become aggressive or destructive.

In the end, both Dobermans and Belgian Malinois can make great personal and property protection dogs, so the deciding factor really comes down to personal preference and what you're looking for in a dog. It's important to do your research, consult with knowledgeable trainers, and, if possible, spend some time around both breeds to see which one is the best fit for you.

alf.ortiz

I have had both a Doberman and a Belgian Malinois, and I have to say that my Doberman was a better personal and property protection dog. He was fiercely loyal to me and my family, and he would always keep an eye out for potential danger. He was also very obedient and protective, but not aggressive or overly dominant, which made him a great companion and a safe dog to have around young children.

I found that the Belgian Malinois, while also intelligent and trainable, had a more difficult and unpredictable temperament. They are known for their strong prey drive and can be more dominant and aggressive than Dobermans. They require a lot of socialization and training to prevent them from becoming overly protective and potentially dangerous to other people and animals.

That being said, I think both breeds can make great protection dogs, but it ultimately depends on the specific dog and how it's raised and trained. I recommend doing thorough research and consulting with experienced trainers before making a decision.

ylindgren

I've owned a Doberman for several years and can attest to their abilities as a personal and property protection dog. My dog is highly intelligent, loyal, and protective, and I feel much safer with him by my side. He is very obedient and easy to train, which has made it easy to teach him how to protect me and my property.

However, it's important to note that Dobermans can be prone to certain health issues, such as arthritis, hip dysplasia, and heart problems, which can affect their ability to function as protection dogs as they age. It's important to stay on top of their health and give them the proper care and support they need to maintain their physical abilities.

Overall, I personally prefer the Doberman over the Belgian Malinois as a protection dog, but it's important to note that each dog is unique and has its own strengths and weaknesses. It's important to do your research and consult with experienced trainers to find the right dog for you.

carrie51

I have a Belgian Malinois as my personal/property protection dog and couldn't be happier. He is highly intelligent and trainable, which has made training him to protect me and my property a breeze. I feel much safer with him around, as he is always alert and ready to protect me if necessary. He is also great with my children - very gentle and patient with them.

However, I have also heard wonderful things about Dobermans as protection dogs. I think both breeds can be highly effective in protecting their owners and their property. It really just comes down to personal preference and what you're looking for in a dog. Dobermans are known for being very loyal to their owners and are highly trainable as well. I recommend doing research on both breeds and even meeting some dogs of each breed to see which one you connect with more.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community