Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Which breed of dog should I buy? A Doberman or a German Shepherd?

Hi everyone,

I am in the market for a new dog and have been considering either a Doberman or a German Shepherd. I live in a suburban area with a decent-sized backyard and have two young children. I work from home, so I will have plenty of time to take care of and train the dog.

I am looking for a loyal and protective companion who can also be a good family pet. I have heard that both breeds are intelligent and trainable, but I am not sure which one would be the better fit for my family and lifestyle.

If anyone has any experience with either breed, I would love to hear your thoughts and recommendations. Thank you in advance for your help!

All Replies


Hi there,

I have experience with Dobermans and German Shepherds as well, and I must say that both breeds would make great pets. I highly agree with user 1 regarding the energy levels of the breed, but I also think there are a few other considerations to take into account.

Dobermans are highly intelligent and loyal dogs with a natural instinct for protection that suits them well in a family setting. They are highly trainable and respond best to positive reinforcement, which can really build their confidence levels.

German Shepherds are also highly intelligent, loyal, and protective dogs that are known for being great with children. They love to work and excel in obedience training and agility. These dogs are highly adaptable to different situations, which makes them a great fit for families.

In conclusion, it is all about individual choice when selecting a breed. While Dobermans require more time and attention, German Shepherds are also a smart choice if you are looking for a dog that loves to exercise and learn. Ultimately, it all comes down to your own personal circumstances and your lifestyle. I hope this helps you make the right decision!


Hi there! I have owned both Dobermans and German Shepherds in the past and each breed has its own unique traits that could match your family's needs.

Dobermans are known for their loyalty, intelligence, and protectiveness. They make great companions and are very affectionate with their owners. However, they can be high-strung and require a lot of training, socialization, and exercise. If you have young children, you may need to be careful as Dobermans can be a bit rough in play.

On the other hand, German Shepherds are also highly intelligent, protective and known to be great family pets. They are highly adaptable to different settings and situations, loyal to their owners and have endless reserves of energy. German Shepherds are highly trainable and require daily exercise, mental stimulation, and socialization. They are good with children, but a little more cautious than Dobermans.

Overall, both breeds are great choices and capable of making wonderful pets. Ultimately, it comes down to your personal preference and lifestyle. If you're looking for a more relaxed dog that won't require too much attention, then I'd suggest a German Shepherd. But, if you are looking for an energetic dog that can keep up with your family and loves to play, then a Doberman might be the one for you. I hope this helps and best of luck choosing your new furry family member!


Hello there,

I have owned a Doberman in the past, and I must say that they make fantastic family pets. They are loyal, protective, and intelligent dogs that will bond closely with their owners. Dobermans are also very adaptable and can fit well into a family with children, provided that they are well-trained and socialized from a young age.

One of the things that really drew me to the Doberman breed was their protective instinct. My Dobie always seemed to have a sixth sense about when I was feeling sad or threatened, and he would go out of his way to comfort me. That being said, this natural protective drive can make them wary of strangers, so it is important to socialize them properly to avoid any potential aggression towards guests in your home.

One thing to bear in mind is that Dobermans are high-energy dogs that require lots of exercise and mental stimulation. If you're an active family that loves hiking, running, and other outdoor activities, a Doberman could be the perfect fit for you. They also tend to shed a lot, so regular grooming is an essential part of their upkeep.

To sum it up, both Dobermans and German Shepherds can make great family pets, it all comes down to your needs and lifestyle. If you are looking for a dog with a strong protective instinct that is agile and intelligent, a Doberman could be a great choice for you. However, if you prefer a dog with a little bit less natural protectiveness and a high trainability quotient, a German Shepherd might be a better fit.


Hello there,

I have owned both a Doberman and a German Shepherd in the past. Both breeds are great choices, but there are some differences you should consider while making your decision.

In my experience, Dobermans can be more high-strung and sensitive as compared to German Shepherds. They have a lot of energy and require lots of exercise and mental stimulation. But if you are willing to put in the work, you will have a loyal and playful companion by your side.

On the other hand, German Shepherds are known to be very intelligent and obedient dogs. They can be trained to do almost anything and excel at various dog competitions. They are also more aloof than Dobermans, so they may take some time to warm up to new people. But once they do, you'll see what an amazing personality they have!

In my opinion, the biggest difference between these two breeds is their natural energy level. If you have an active family and enjoy long walks in the park or runs, a Doberman will be a perfect match for you. However, if you lead a more relaxed lifestyle and prefer a pet that is not very demanding, then a German Shepherd is a good fit.

Whatever your choice may be, both these breeds will make great pets and are sure to enrich your life. I hope I could help you in making the right decision.


Hey there,

I have only owned a German Shepherd in the past, so I can't speak directly to the experience of owning a Doberman. However, my German Shepherd was an absolutely amazing dog and I think he would have been a great fit for a family with children.

One thing to note is the level of exercise and mental stimulation that German Shepherds require. They are very active dogs and love to go for walks and play. Without adequate exercise and mental stimulation, they can become restless and develop destructive behaviors. That being said, if you have an active family and can devote plenty of time to your dog, a German Shepherd can make a wonderful addition to your home.

Another thing to consider is the grooming needs of the breed. German Shepherds have a thick coat that sheds heavily, so regular brushing is required to keep their coat healthy and shiny. They also require regular baths and upkeep of their nails.

Overall, I love the loyalty, intelligence, and love for children that German Shepherds possess. They can be wonderful additions to any family looking for an active and loving companion. However, if you are looking for specific protection qualities from your dog, a Doberman may be a better fit for you.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community