Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:
92
Q:

Which dog breed should I get, Doberman, Labrador or German Shepherd?

Hi everyone!

I am currently looking to adopt a dog and I am torn between three breeds: Doberman, Labrador, and German Shepherd. I live in a house with a small yard and have a family with two children. We have had a dog before, but it was a small breed and unfortunately passed away due to old age.

I am looking for a dog that is good with children, protective of the family, and easy to train. I work from home, so I will have time to take care of the dog and give it attention. However, I would prefer a breed that is not too high maintenance, especially in terms of grooming.

I have researched these breeds, but I would love to hear from fellow dog owners who have experience with them. Which breed do you think would be the best fit for my family and lifestyle? Any advice or tips would be greatly appreciated! Thank you in advance.

All Replies

catharine.weber

Hi there!

I have owned a Labrador for the past five years and I have to say they are the perfect family dog. They are incredibly friendly, playful and good with children. They are easy to train and are known for their loyalty towards their family. In terms of grooming, they do shed quite a bit, but regular brushing and baths can help with that.

Dobermans and German Shepherds are great breeds, but they are known to be more high maintenance than Labradors. They do require a lot of training and socialization, and need plenty of exercise to keep them healthy and happy. Unlike Labradors, they may also have a natural tendency to be protective of their family and territory, which can be a good thing but also requires careful training and management.

In my opinion, given that you have a family with two children and a small yard, a Labrador would be the best fit for your lifestyle. They are social dogs and do best when they are around people, so working from home will be perfect for your furry friend. They also don't require as much exercise as the other two breeds, so they will be happy with a daily walk and playtime in the yard.

Hope this helps!

malcolm01

Hello friend,

I have been a proud owner of a German Shepherd for the past three years, and I must say that I have enjoyed every moment with my dog. I believe that German Shepherds make fantastic family pets particularly when they are properly trained and socialized.

The only downside is that they shed quite heavily and require regular grooming, but you are probably better of knowing that Dobermans also have the same tendencies. That said, German Shepherds require a lot of exercise, attention, and proper training due to their high intelligence and energy level. Also, they perform exceptionally well as guard dogs and will do anything to protect their family and territory.

In your situation, since you have small children, they might enjoy playing with a dog that is more active like a German Shepherd rather than a Lab or a Doberman. If you are up to the task of providing enough exercise, training, love, and attention to the dog, go for a German Shepherd.

Finally, keep in mind that all three breeds have their own strengths and weaknesses, so it is advisable to understand them better, go around for breed experience, and then make the best choice that suits your lifestyle and family.

I hope this helps!

dicki.josie

Hello everyone!

I have owned a Doberman Pinscher for four years, and I absolutely adore this breed. In my personal experience, Dobermans are smart, loyal, and loving dogs who thrive on attention and love to be close to their owners. They are natural protectors and show their loyalty by being fiercely protective of their family members.

Dobermans are incredibly energetic and require a good amount of exercise, making them perfect for families who love to go on outdoor adventures, go for long walks or runs. They also have a reputation for being one of the best breeds for training, as they are quick learners and are extremely intelligent.

In terms of grooming, Dobermans have short, smooth coats that are easy to care for. They can be prone to certain medical issues like hip dysplasia and heart problems, so it's important to do your research on breeders and ensure that your dog comes from a healthy lineage.

Based on your family's active lifestyle, I believe a Doberman could be a good fit. They are excellent with kids and have a natural tendency to be protective of them, which is a great quality in a family dog. However, as with any dog, do your research on the breed to ensure it is a good fit for your family and lifestyle.

I hope this helps in your search for the perfect furry friend!

wboyer

Hello,

I have owned both a Labrador and a German Shepherd, and they are both fantastic breeds in their own way. Labradors are known for their friendly and loyal nature and make great family pets. They are easy to train and require moderate exercise, making them a low-maintenance breed.

On the other hand, German Shepherds are highly intelligent, loyal and protective dogs. They require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation on a daily basis. If you are up for the challenge of exercising your dog regularly, then you will end up with an incredibly loyal friend who has a strong protective instinct for their family.

If you have a small yard, a Labrador would be a better fit than a German Shepherd, as the latter needs a lot of space to play and run around. One thing to keep in mind, however, is that Labradors can be quite boisterous and jumpy, which can be a concern for small children. You will need to train them to be gentle around children in order to avoid accidents.

In conclusion, both breeds have their strengths and weaknesses, and it's important to choose a dog that fits your family's lifestyle and personality. If you're looking for a more laid-back dog, then a Labrador would be a great choice. If you're looking for a dog that is more alert and protective, then a German Shepherd would be the better choice.

Good luck with your decision!

nbernier

Hello,

I am a proud owner of a Labrador Retriever for almost a decade now. I believe they are one of the most versatile, friendly, and intelligent dog breeds in the world. They have a lovely, obedient nature, which makes them great with kids and other animals.

Labradors are very social and enjoy being around their owners. That said, they need plenty of exercise, and if you can't provide that, they can get bored, overweight, and destructive. Also, Labradors tend to shed their fur quite often, so regular grooming is essential to keep their coat clean and healthy.

Based on your description of your family and home environment, I highly recommend Labradors as a perfect pet breed for you. They are incredibly friendly, even-tempered, and easy to care for. They are highly trainable and love learning new tricks. Besides, having a lab in your family would ensure that your kids get enough exercise, and they would also have a constant companion to play and cuddle with.

As with any dog breed, choosing the right pet can be a complicated decision. However, some common factors that determine the best pet breed for you include space, temperament, grooming needs, and energy levels. Be sure to research extensively and interact with various breeds before committing yourself to one.

Good luck and happy pet parenting!

zulauf.lera

Hi there,

I have owned a Doberman for the past two years and I think they make great pets. Dobermans are very loyal and protective of their families, and they have a reputation for being excellent guard dogs. However, they do require a lot of attention and exercise to keep them happy and healthy.

In terms of grooming, Dobermans are low maintenance dogs that don't shed much. They can be prone to allergies and skin issues, so regular grooming and cleaning of their ears and teeth is essential. Although they are naturally protective, they also need proper socialization and training to be well behaved around children and other pets.

With respect to your situation, I would suggest that you consider a Doberman, especially if you are looking for a breed that could protect your family. However, they are high-energy dogs that require plenty of physical and mental exercise, so you must be willing to put in the necessary time and effort. They are typically best suited to active families, but if you can provide enough stimulation, attention and exercise to your dog, a Doberman could be an excellent addition to your family.

That said, whichever breed you choose, make sure you have done your research and ensure that you are making the right decision for the well-being of both your family and the dog.

I hope this helps.

hamill.alisa

Hey there,

I've owned a German Shepherd for six years now, and I couldn't be happier with my choice of breed. German Shepherds are known for their intelligence, loyalty, and protectiveness. They are incredibly versatile dogs, and I've trained mine to do everything from obedience and agility to search and rescue work.

One thing to keep in mind is that German Shepherds need a job to do or some kind of mental stimulation to keep them from becoming bored or destructive. If you're willing to put in the work, though, they can be the ultimate breed for both active families and people who want a dog to train and engage with.

German Shepherds also require a good amount of grooming, especially during shedding season, so be prepared to brush your dog regularly and potentially bring them to a groomer if you're not comfortable trimming their nails and bathing them yourself.

Overall, if you're looking for a breed that is intelligent, adaptable, protective, and potentially able to work in more advanced areas like search and rescue or even serving as service dogs, I'd definitely recommend a German Shepherd.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community