Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Which dog is more protective of its owner, the German Shepherd or the Doberman?

Hey, I am a first-time dog owner and I'm trying to decide between a German Shepherd and a Doberman. I live in a not-so-safe neighborhood, and I want a dog that can protect me and my family if need be. I've heard that both German Shepherds and Dobermans are great watchdogs, but I'm not sure which one is more protective of its owner. Can anyone share their experiences with these breeds and give me some advice? Thank you!

All Replies


I had a German Shepherd and a Doberman as well, and I would say that my German Shepherd was more protective of me. She had a natural instinct to protect her family and would always stand between us and any perceived danger. However, my Doberman was also very loyal and protective of me, and I never had to worry when he was around. I think both breeds make great watchdogs and protectors, but it's important to remember that they are not just guard dogs. They need love, attention, and proper training to become well-behaved and happy pets.


I have a German Shepherd and he is extremely protective of me and my family. When we go on walks, he always watches our surroundings and barks if he senses any sort of danger. He is also very loyal and knows who is part of our family and who isn't. However, I've heard that Dobermans are also great protectors and can be more intense than German Shepherds. I think it really depends on the individual dog's personality and training. I would suggest meeting both breeds and seeing which one you feel more comfortable with before making a decision.


I have had both a German Shepherd and a Doberman, and in my experience, the Doberman was more protective of me as his owner. He was incredibly loyal and would not hesitate to step in if he felt I was in danger. However, I agree that it ultimately comes down to the individual dog's personality and training. My German Shepherd was also very protective of me and my family, but she was more gentle with strangers and didn't have the same level of intensity as my Doberman. I think it's important to spend time with different breeds and individual dogs to see which one suits your lifestyle and needs best.


I would suggest going for a German Shepherd. I have owned German Shepherds for over a decade now, and I can testify that they are extremely protective of their owners. They are loyal and intelligent dogs that are often used by police and military for their watchdog abilities. My German Shepherd has always been alert and watchful, and once when an unknown person tried to enter my house, my dog's barking and aggressive behavior scared off the intruder. Also, German Shepherds make great family pets, and I'm sure yours will be very protective of you and your family.


I think both German Shepherds and Dobermans can be very protective of their owners, but it really depends on the dog's personality and training. I have owned both breeds, and while my German Shepherd was very loyal and protective of me, my Doberman was actually more aggressive and has been known to protect me and my family. I think it's essential to socialize and train your dog to be protective but not to be overly aggressive. It's also vital to remember that owning a protective dog comes with a lot of responsibility, and you must be prepared to provide them with the necessary training, exercise, and socialization.


While I agree that German Shepherds are pretty protective of their owners, I believe that Dobermans are a lot better in this aspect. From my personal experience, my Doberman has always been incredibly affectionate and fiercely loyal to me and my family. He's a natural watchdog and is always on alert for any potential danger. Once, when we were walking together, and someone came too close to me, he immediately placed himself in front of me, barked, and growled until the person backed off. Besides, Dobermans have an intimidating look, which can deter anyone trying to harm you. Overall, I would suggest you go for a Doberman if you want a very protective dog.


I have a Doberman and he is incredibly protective of me. When we go out for a walk, he always walks on my left side and stays alert to any potential danger. He is very loyal to me and follows me everywhere I go. However, he can be a bit intense with strangers, especially if they come into our home. I have to make sure he gets proper socialization and training to prevent any aggressive behavior. That being said, I still feel very safe when he is around and I think he would do everything in his power to protect me if needed. Ultimately, both German Shepherds and Dobermans are great protectors and I think it comes down to personal preference and individual dog personalities.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community