Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:
620
Q:

Which dog would be capable of inflicting the most pain on a human between the Doberman, Rottweiler and German Shepherd?

Hi all,

I am considering getting a guard dog for my home as I live alone in a not so safe area. While doing my research, I came across some information about the Doberman, Rottweiler and German Shepherd breeds. I understand that all three of these breeds are great guard dogs and have a knack for protecting their owners. However, I am concerned about the potential harm they can cause in case of an attack on a human. I am not planning on training my dog to attack a human, but in case of a home invasion, I want to make sure that my dog would be capable of inflicting enough pain on the attacker to defend me. So my question is, which of these breeds would be capable of inflicting the most pain on a human between the Doberman, Rottweiler and German Shepherd? I appreciate any insights and advice you can offer me on this topic. Thanks in advance.

All Replies

christiansen.leta

Hi everyone,

I have been a dog trainer for several years and have experience working with all three of these breeds. While it's true that all three can make great guard dogs, it's important to remember that the individual personality and temperament of the dog is what matters most.

When it comes to training a dog for protection, I always emphasize the importance of positive reinforcement training. This means rewarding good behavior with treats and praise, rather than punishing bad behavior. Positive reinforcement training has been shown to be the most effective way to train a dog and can help ensure that your dog is well-behaved and obedient.

When it comes to the question of which breed would be most capable of inflicting pain on a human, I have to agree with the other users that it's not an appropriate question to ask. As a trainer, my focus is always on training a dog to protect their owner without causing harm to anyone.

Ultimately, the best guard dog for you will depend on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and experience with dogs. It's important to do your research and talk to breeders, trainers, and other dog owners before making a decision.

I hope this information is helpful.

schulist.lura

Hello,

I have had experience with all three breeds and I have to say that each one has their own unique traits that make them great guard dogs. Dobermans are known to be very alert and territorial, while Rottweilers have a great sense of smell and can pick up on any unusual scents in their surrounding area. German Shepherds are very intelligent and can quickly learn commands, making them great at following instructions.

I agree with User 2 about the importance of training and socializing your dog. While it's important to have a guard dog that can protect you, it's equally important that they don't pose a threat to other humans or animals. I believe that any dog has the potential to cause harm if they are not properly trained or if they feel threatened.

Ultimately, the decision of which breed to choose as a guard dog should be based on your personal preferences and lifestyle. It's important that you do your research and talk to breeders or other dog owners to get a sense of what each breed is like.

I hope this information helps you make an informed decision.

annie.kuphal

Hi there,

I have owned both a Doberman and a Rottweiler in the past, and I can tell you that both breeds are extremely loyal and protective of their owners. While I never trained my dogs to attack humans, they were very territorial and would bark and growl at any strangers that came near my property. In terms of which breed would be more capable of inflicting pain on a human, I would have to say that it depends on the individual dog and their temperament. Both Dobermans and Rottweilers have powerful jaws and can be very intimidating, but they can also be trained to be gentle and loving pets.

That being said, I have also heard great things about German Shepherds as guard dogs. They have a long history of being used as police and military dogs, so they are well-trained and obedient. I think the most important thing when choosing a guard dog is to find a breed that fits your lifestyle and personality. All three of these breeds require a lot of training and socialization to be good pets, but they can also be very rewarding companions if raised properly.

Hope this helps!

joy.little

Greetings,

I currently own a German Shepherd, and he is by far one of the most intelligent and loyal dogs I have ever had. I did a lot of research before deciding on this breed, and what stood out to me most was their high level of trainability and obedience. While German Shepherds are known for their guarding instincts, they are also very loving and affectionate towards their families.

In terms of which of the three breeds would be most capable of inflicting pain on a human, I don't think it's appropriate to frame the question that way. A dog's purpose should never be to cause harm to humans. While it's important to have a dog that will protect you, it's equally important to prioritize their safety and well-being too.

As a responsible dog owner, it's important to train and socialize your dog, regardless of breed, to ensure they are well-behaved and obedient. This will not only make them more effective in protecting you, but it will also give you a better quality of life with your dog.

I hope this perspective helps.

domenico14

Hi there,

I have owned both a Rottweiler and a German Shepherd in the past, and I can speak to the loyalty and protective nature of these breeds. However, I think it's important to remember that owning a guard dog comes with a lot of responsibility.

As a dog owner, it's our responsibility to ensure our dogs are properly trained and socialized, regardless of breed. A well-trained dog that has been socialized to interact well with humans and other animals is much less likely to cause harm to anyone.

If you're looking for a guard dog, I would recommend doing your research and finding a reputable breeder who emphasizes socialization and positive reinforcement training. It's also important to work with a reputable trainer who has experience working with the specific breed you choose.

In my opinion, any dog can make a great guard dog if they have been properly trained and socialized. The key is to find a breed that fits your lifestyle and personality, and to put in the time and effort to properly train and care for them.

I hope this information is helpful!

frami.dora

Hello,

I have owned two Rottweilers in the past and can attest to their great loyalty and protective nature. When raised properly, Rottweilers can be an ideal choice as a guard dog. However, it's important to remember that they are a powerful breed and require a strong, confident owner who can establish themselves as the pack leader.

In terms of which breed would be most capable of inflicting pain on a human, I agree with User 2 that it's not an appropriate way to frame the question. It's important to focus on training and socialization to ensure that your dog will be a safe and effective protector.

All three breeds have their own strengths and weaknesses when it comes to guarding. Dobermans are known for their speed and agility, Rottweilers for their powerful physique, and German Shepherds for their intelligence and loyalty. Ultimately, the best breed for you will depend on your lifestyle, living situation, and personal preferences.

One thing to keep in mind is that owning a guard dog comes with a lot of responsibility. It's important to be prepared for the time and effort it takes to properly train and care for a dog, especially one that is trained for protection purposes.

I hope this helps!

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community