Hey everyone, I'm looking to get a guard dog for my home and I'm torn between three popular breeds - Doberman, Rottweiler, and Belgian. I live in a suburban area and I want a dog that can protect me and my family while also being a good companion. I've heard that these breeds are all great guard dogs, but I'm not sure which one would be the best fit for me.
I don't have any other pets, but I have young children, so I'm looking for a breed that is good with kids. I also have a decent-sized yard, so I want a dog that has space to run around and exercise. I'm willing to train my dog and provide it with proper care, but I want a breed that is not too difficult to train.
Based on your experiences and expertise, which of these breeds would you recommend for me? What are some pros and cons of each breed that I should consider before making a decision? Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

Hi there, as someone who has owned both a Rottweiler and a Doberman, I can speak to my personal experience with both breeds. Both dogs were excellent guard dogs and were good with my children, but there were some notable differences between the two.
The Rottweiler was larger in size and had a more intimidating presence. He was naturally protective of our home and family and didn't require as much training in that regard. However, he did require regular exercise and had a tendency to be lazy if not given enough physical activity. He was also prone to health issues, such as hip dysplasia and ACL tears, which required expensive medical care.
Our Doberman, on the other hand, was more energetic and required more training to become a good guard dog. He was smaller in size but still had a commanding presence, and he was able to run faster and for longer periods of time. We found him to be more adaptable in different situations and easier to train overall. However, he did have a tendency to be more anxious and needy, and he required a lot of mental stimulation in addition to physical exercise.
Overall, both breeds were great guard dogs and loving companions, but I found the Doberman to be more adaptable and easier to train. However, it's important to note that every dog is unique and has its own personality, so it's important to do your research and find a reputable breeder who can answer your specific questions and help you find a dog that suits your individual needs.