Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:
80
Q:

Which is a better dog, the Doberman or the Bullmastiff?

Hey everyone,

I'm in the market for a new dog and I'm torn between two breeds: the Doberman and the Bullmastiff. I live in a medium-sized apartment but also have a decent-sized yard for the dog to play in. I'm looking for a dog that will be loyal, protective and good with children.

I've heard great things about both breeds - the Doberman is supposed to be intelligent and easy to train while the Bullmastiff is known for being gentle and great with children. However, I've also heard that both breeds can be a bit stubborn and require a firm hand in training.

I'm leaning towards the Bullmastiff because of their reputation as wonderful family dogs, but I'm curious to hear from anyone who has had experience with either breed. Which one do you think would be a better fit for me?

Thanks in advance for your help!

All Replies

deven33

Hey,

I've owned a Bullmastiff for the past 3 years, and she has been the perfect fit for me and my family. From my experience, she is one of the most gentle dogs I have ever owned. She is great with kids and other pets, and she's just happy to be around people.

In terms of exercise, I would say that she requires only moderate amounts. She loves going for a walk, but she's just as happy lounging on the couch with us. Her shedding is minimal, which is great for someone who doesn't want to stay on top of grooming.

Additionally, my Bullmastiff is slightly less vocal than my previous dog, which is ideal for someone who prefers a quieter pet. However, as another user had pointed out, they do need consistent training and reinforcement, so I recommend a good obedience program.

All in all, I do recommend the Bullmastiff to anyone looking for a low-energy, easy-going, and gentle dog that loves to spend time with you. This breed is incredibly loyal and protective but will only act on instinct, so they are not naturally as guarding oriented as Dobermans.

bo75

Hey there,

I actually have experience with both breeds and can offer some insight into which might be a better fit for you. I currently have a Doberman and he is an absolute joy to have around. He is incredibly intelligent and easy to train, which is a huge plus. He is also very loyal and protective of our family. However, I will say that he does require a lot of exercise and mental stimulation to keep him from getting bored.

On the other hand, I previously had a Bullmastiff and he was also a wonderful dog. He was incredibly gentle with my children and was always eager to please. He didn't require as much exercise as my Doberman, but he did shed quite a bit.

Ultimately, I think both breeds could be a good fit for you depending on your lifestyle and preferences. If you're willing to put in the time and effort to properly train and exercise a Doberman, I think they make fantastic pets. But if you're looking for a slightly more laid-back option, the Bullmastiff could also be a great choice.

Hope this helps!

batz.leonie

Hi everyone,

I just wanted to provide my experience with owning a Doberman Pinscher. I have owned my Doberman for two years now, and I must say she is one of the most intelligent and loving dogs I have ever had.

I am an active person, so having a dog that needed a lot of exercise was a perfect fit for me. My Doberman needs at least an hour of exercise daily, and she keeps me busy. This breed is also incredibly smart, and they have a natural inclination towards learning that can make training them quite easy.

Socialization is key for this breed, and I had to put in quite an effort to make sure she got the required socialization she needed. Now, she is great with children and other pets and even enhances the liveliness of my home.

I also want to mention that while Dobermans are known for being protective and guarding naturally, they can also be very playful and affectionate. My Dobie loves nothing more than cuddling with me on the sofa at the end of the day.

However, I would agree with the other users that owning a Dobie does require time, effort, and energy. This breed is not recommended for first-time owners or someone who cannot dedicate adequate time and attention to the dog.

In conclusion, I believe that the Doberman Pinscher is an excellent breed for someone looking for an active, intelligent, and protective companion. They require a lot of socialization and training, but the payoff is a loyal and loving dog that just wants to be with you.

daphne02

Hello,

I have had both a Bullmastiff and a Doberman in my life, and I would say that both breeds have some amazing qualities. However, if I had to pick one, I would go with the Bullmastiff.

My Bullmastiff was incredibly affectionate and gentle, especially with children. He was patient and never showed any signs of aggression. He never required much grooming, and he didn't need as much exercise as our Doberman does currently. So if you're someone who is looking for a laid-back, low-key dog that gets along well with children, I think the Bullmastiff is a great choice.

Don't get me wrong - Dobermans are fantastic dogs as well. They are smart and loyal and can be great with kids, but as other users have pointed out, they do require a lot of time and attention. They need daily exercise and mental stimulation, and they can quickly become destructive if they don't get enough attention.

Overall, I believe that the Bullmastiff is an ideal breed for a family who wants a gentle, loyal dog that will get along well with kids and other pets. However, if you're looking for a highly active and intelligent dog that will require more exercise and attention, then the Doberman might be a better fit.

cjacobs

Hello all,

I have owned a Doberman for the past two years, and I must say that I am extremely happy with my decision. My Doberman is incredibly loyal and loving, and I think the breed's intelligence sets it apart from others.

My Doberman is very playful and is always eager to learn new tricks. He enjoys accompanying me on hikes and long walks and is always up for a game of fetch. Additionally, I have found that he does well with children and visitors to our home.

I will admit that Dobermans do require a lot of exercise, both physical and mental. They are an intelligent breed requiring plenty of stimulation to prevent boredom which can lead to them destructing around the house. Also, they need proper training and socialization that must be consistent, in my opinion. Otherwise, they can become too possessive of their family, which can manifest in aggressive behavior.

Overall, I am very happy with my Doberman, and I believe that they make great pets. However, I would definitely recommend that you do your research and make sure that a Doberman's specific needs align with your lifestyle and other pets.

legros.stewart

Hi there,

I just wanted to chime in and give my vote for the Bullmastiff. Last year, we added one to our family, and have been so happy that we did. It's important to mention that he has needed quite a bit of reinforcement training. However, the amount of love he has given us in return has been more than worth the time and resource dedicated to him even till now.

I believe training or reinforcement training is a priority with the Bullmastiff breed, so if you have the time and patience to work with your Bullmastiff on this, he will reward you with a gentle, fun-loving, and loyal companion.

With respect to children, he is naturally gentle around them and seems to understand the need to be cautious with them.

As for exercise, his needs are moderate, and he happily joins in whenever we feel like jogging, hiking, or playing outdoor games, so as far as I'm concerned, he perfectly fits your criterion for a wonderful family pet.

Best of luck in making your decision.

dangelo.wunsch

Hi all,

I just wanted to touch on the protective nature of both breeds since it seems to be a concern for the original poster. I have owned both a Bullmastiff and a Doberman, and both breeds have the potential to be very protective of their families.

However, I would say that in my experience, the Bullmastiff is more likely to be passive about guarding, while the Doberman is more proactive. This doesn't necessarily mean that one is better than the other, as it depends on what you're looking for in a dog.

For example, if you live in an area where there is a lot of crime, a Doberman might be a better choice because they are more likely to proactively guard their territory. On the other hand, if you're looking for a dog that will mostly just deter potential intruders with their size and presence, a Bullmastiff might be a better fit.

It's also worth noting that both breeds should be socialized early on to help them develop good manners around strangers. Even a dog who is naturally friendly can become aggressive if they feel like their space is being invaded or their family is being threatened.

All in all, both breeds are amazing pets, it absolutely depends on your lifestyle, expectations, and personal preference.

murphy.forrest

Hi everyone,

I just wanted to give my two cents worth of experience with Dobermans. I have owned two Dobermans, and I must say that they are amazing dogs that can be the ideal pet when trained and socialized properly.

Our first Doberman was a rescue, and it took a while to get him to trust us. However, once he did, he was one of the most loyal and loving dogs I've ever had. He was great with kids and other animals and loved nothing more than cuddling up to us on the couch.

Our current Doberman is a puppy and is so full of energy and love. She is extremely intelligent, and we have been very impressed with how much she has learned so far. Even though she is high-energy, we have found that making sure she gets plenty of exercise and attention has been key to managing her needs.

Overall, I think both breeds have their pros and cons, but I am a huge fan of the Doberman breed. They are extremely smart, loyal, and agile, making them perfect for families that want an active dog. However, they do need a lot of attention, so if you aren't prepared to give them the time and dedication they need, then it's probably not the right breed for you.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community