Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Which is the most loyal and the best family guard dog, a German Shepherd or a Doberman Pinscher?

Hey everyone,

I am considering getting a family guard dog and have been doing some research on which breed is the best fit for my family. I have narrowed it down to German Shepherds and Doberman Pinschers. I am aware that both breeds are known for their loyalty and protection abilities, but I am unsure which one would be the best fit for my family.

I have a wife and two young children, so I need a dog that is not only protective but also great with kids. We live in a residential neighborhood, so I don't need a dog that is too aggressive or territorial. Ideally, I want a dog that is obedient, trainable, intelligent and has a strong protective instinct.

I have read that German Shepherds are great family dogs and have been known to be used as service dogs and police dogs due to their intelligence and loyalty. Whereas Dobermans are known for their speed, agility, and high energy levels, and are ideal for families that enjoy outdoor activities.

Overall, I want a dog that is a good companion to my family and also doubles up as a guard dog when needed. Based on my preferences, which breed would be the better choice for my family - a German Shepherd or a Doberman Pinscher?

Thank you in advance for your help and advice!

All Replies


Hello everyone,

I would have to agree that both German Shepherds and Doberman Pinschers are great family guard dogs, but I think it depends on your family's lifestyle and needs. I have owned both breeds and can attest to their loyalty and protective nature.

In my experience, German Shepherds tend to be more reserved than Dobermans and require a lot of socialization as puppies to ensure their temperament remains stable into adulthood. However, they are highly intelligent and trainable dogs that have varied temperaments. German Shepherds can be either highly energetic or calm and reserved around family, depending on early socialization and training. They are excellent guard dogs, and their mere presence is often enough to deter intruders.

On the other hand, Doberman Pinschers are more predisposed to have a higher energy level and can be more demanding of their owners' time and attention. They can become bored and destructive if they don't get enough exercise or mental stimulation. But as mentioned earlier, they are excellent guards and bond well with family members, making them effective watchdogs.

Both breeds are relatively easy to train and are highly protective of their families. So, I guess it all depends on what you are looking for in a family guard dog. You should choose a breed that will fit into your family's lifestyle, activity level, and energy level.

In summary, I would recommend a German Shepherd if you are looking for an intelligent and loyal dog that can also double up as a great guard dog. If you are looking for a dog that has more energy and would be a better fit for an active family, then a Doberman Pinscher may be a better choice.

I hope this helps.


Hey there,

In my personal experience, I would have to recommend a German Shepherd as the best family guard dog. I have owned two German Shepherds in the past, and they were both incredibly loyal, trainable, intelligent, and protective of my family. They were great with my children, and I never had to worry about them being too aggressive or territorial.

German Shepherds are natural protectors and have a strong work-drive, which makes them easy to train as guard dogs. They are also known for their calm and composed demeanor and are generally friendly towards strangers unless their family is threatened. I have found that they are great watchdogs that will bark to alert you of any potential danger.

While Doberman Pinschers are also great guard dogs, I think they are better suited for families that are active and enjoy outdoor activities. They require a lot of physical exercise and stimulation to prevent them from becoming bored and destructive. In my opinion, they are not as easy to train as German Shepherds, and their temperament can be unpredictable if not trained properly.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference and lifestyle. If you have an active family and love spending time outdoors, then a Doberman Pinscher might be the better choice. However, if you want a loyal, intelligent, and trainable companion that can also double up as a guard dog, then a German Shepherd is the way to go.

Hope this helps!



From my experience, I believe that a Doberman Pinscher is the best family guard dog. I have owned a Doberman for over 5 years now, and it has been an excellent guard dog and family companion. Dobermans tend to be more high-energy and require more exercise than German Shepherds. However, they are very loyal, affectionate and intelligent dogs that are great with children.

The protective instincts of Dobermans are unparalleled in the canine world. Their incredible speed and agility make them deadly against intruders. When a Doberman senses a potential threat to their family, they immediately go on guard mode, making it almost impossible for anyone to get close to you without being noticed.

Contrary to what the widely held belief might be, Dobermans are known for their excellent temperament and are not aggressive, which makes them ideal family dogs. They are very obedient and can be easily trained to become great guard dogs.

Additionally, loyalty is a watchword of the Doberman breed. They are extremely loyal to their owners and can form a deep bond with every member of the family, which they will defend against any threat. So, I believe that a Doberman can effectively double up as a loyal companion and guard dog, which is all you would want in a family pet.

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference, and you should go with what suits your lifestyle and family. However, if you're looking for a fiercely loyal and protective dog that doubles up as a high-energy companion, then a Doberman Pinscher is the way to go.

I hope this helps.


Hello there,

I am glad to see that everyone has recommended great family guard dogs. While both breeds are wonderful and have their own unique traits, I would like to share my personal experience with Rottweilers as family guard dogs.

I have owned Rottweilers for many years and can testify to their loyalty, protectiveness, and playfulness. They are similar in size to Dobermans and German Shepherds and have a reputation for being an excellent guard dog.

Rottweilers are often misunderstood because of their aggressive reputation, but when properly trained and socialized, they make fantastic family guard dogs. They are intelligent, obedient, and devoted to their owners, which makes them effective guard dogs.

Rottweilers are also playful and love to be around their families, and their presence is usually enough to ward off potential predators. They have a great sense of loyalty and can be very affectionate and gentle around children. Besides, they are usually quite calm, and their mellow demeanor makes them ideal for families that prefer a laid-back dog.

However, before choosing a Rottweiler, it is essential to understand that they require firm and consistent training. Early socialization is essential to keep their protective instincts in check and prevent them from being overly aggressive towards strangers. They are also large and powerful dogs that need regular exercise and mental stimulation.

In conclusion, Rottweilers are a great choice for a family guard dog if you are prepared to put in the time and effort required to train and socialize them. They are loyal, loving, and protective of their owners, making them an excellent addition to any family.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community