Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Why do some people shorten the tail and/or ears of a Doberman Pinscher, Rottweiler, etc?

Hi everyone, I am new to the world of dog breeding and have recently started to read about certain breeds that have their tails and ears shortened. I came across Doberman Pinschers and Rottweilers who have their tails and/or ears docked. I am curious to know why people do this and if it is a common practice. From what I have read, the reason behind it is mostly for cosmetic purposes, but I couldn't understand why anyone would put their dogs through such a painful procedure just for looks. I would appreciate it if someone can shed some light on this topic and help me understand the rationale behind it. Thank you in advance!

All Replies


Hi everyone! As someone who is planning to adopt a Rottweiler in the near future, I have researched tail docking and ear cropping quite extensively. While I understand that some people like the appearance of a docked tail or cropped ears, I have personally decided against it for my own pet.

Aside from the potential health risks and the debate about the ethics of these procedures, I feel that my Rottweiler will be just as beautiful and unique with a natural tail and ears. In fact, I think the natural look adds to the breed's character and individuality.

Furthermore, I believe that it's important to set trends that prioritize a dog's well-being over aesthetic preferences. I think the tendency to dock tails and crop ears is a reflection of outdated trends and beliefs. As we learn more about dog health and behavior, we should strive to prioritize what is good for the dog, rather than just what looks good.

In conclusion, I would encourage those considering tail docking or ear cropping to think carefully about the decision and prioritize their dog's health above all else. Ultimately, our pets rely on us to make responsible choices for their well-being, so we should take that responsibility seriously.


Hi there! As a veterinary student, I have learned about the practice of tail docking and ear cropping in certain dog breeds. From a medical perspective, these procedures are not necessary for the health and well-being of the dog, and they carry risks such as infection, bleeding, and pain.

Moreover, cropping or docking a dog's tail or ears can have a negative impact on their behavior and socialization. Tail docking in particular can disrupt a dog's ability to communicate effectively with other dogs, as the tail is often used to signal different emotions and intentions. Ear cropping can also cause pain and discomfort, and may even lead to hearing loss if not done properly.

As a future veterinarian, my priority will always be to promote the health and welfare of our furry friends. While I understand that some people prefer the look of a docked or cropped dog, I strongly believe that this should not come at the cost of the dog's comfort and well-being.

In conclusion, I would advise pet owners to avoid tail docking and ear cropping whenever possible, and to prioritize their pet's health and welfare above all else. At the end of the day, our furry friends rely on us to make responsible choices on their behalf, and it's up to us to ensure that they are living happy, healthy lives.


Hi everyone! As someone who has a Rottweiler with a naturally long tail and uncropped ears, I can say that I have never once regretted my decision to leave them natural. In fact, I find that my dog's natural tail and ears add to his personality and uniqueness, and I wouldn't want him to look any different.

Aside from personal preferences, I think it's important to consider the ethics of docking and cropping, especially given the fact that these practices are banned in many countries. The surgeries carry risks and are often done without anesthesia, which is concerning from a welfare perspective.

Furthermore, there is no practical reason to dock or crop a pet dog's tail or ears in today's world. The practices were initially done for practical reasons such as preventing injury during hunting or working activities, but these reasons are no longer relevant for most pet dogs.

In conclusion, I would strongly advise against docking or cropping a dog's tail or ears for aesthetic purposes, and instead advise pet owners to embrace their dog's natural appearance. After all, our pets are individuals with their own personalities and unique features, and there's no reason to alter their appearance for the sake of tradition or conformity.


Hello everyone! As someone who has owned both Docked and Undocked Doberman Pinschers, I can say that there is a noticeable difference in the overall appearance of the dog. However, personal appearance choices aside, there are some practical reasons to consider docking a Doberman's tail, especially if they are working dogs that engage in hunting or guarding activities.

Doberman Pinschers, in particular, have an excitable nature and a habit of wagging their tails vigorously when they are happy or alert. This can lead to tail injuries or even broken bones, especially for dogs that are active and exercise often. Docking the tail can prevent such injuries and keep the dog healthy and pain-free.

However, it's important to note that docking should be done when the dog is very young, preferably within the first few days of birth. At this early age, the dog's nervous system is not as developed, and the procedure is less painful than it would be for an older dog. Additionally, it should be done under proper veterinary care to ensure the safety and health of the dog.

In conclusion, while the decision to dock or not dock a dog's tail is subjective and varies from person to person, I personally believe that it is a responsible and reasonable decision for anyone with a working Doberman Pinscher. Ultimately, ensuring the safety and well-being of our pets should be the priority.


Hi there! I have owned a Doberman Pinscher for several years and can tell you that the practice of tail docking and ear cropping is quite common in the breed. The American Kennel Club (AKC) breed standard actually calls for both practices to enhance the Doberman's sleek appearance. However, some argue that these procedures are unnecessary and even cruel, as they involve surgically removing parts of the dog's body without any medical benefit.

That being said, my Doberman was docked as a puppy before we adopted him, and he has not exhibited any negative effects from it. He is still able to wag his shortened tail with just as much enthusiasm as a fully intact tail, and his ears stand up straight without the need for cropping.

Personally, though, I don't think I would choose to dock or crop any future dogs I own. I see no practical purpose in it, and I don't want to put my pets through any unnecessary pain or risk of complications. I think it's important for us as pet owners to consider the well-being of our animals above all else, rather than conforming to arbitrary breed standards.


Hello everyone! As a veterinary technician, I have assisted with many tail docking and ear cropping procedures over the years. While they are certainly not my favorite surgeries to perform, I understand that some breeders and owners choose to do so for aesthetic reasons.

It is important to note, however, that these surgeries do come with risks and potential complications. For example, tail docking can lead to chronic pain, infections, and abnormal growths later in life. Ear cropping can cause pain and infections if not done properly or if the dog is not properly cared for afterwards.

Additionally, it's important to recognize that tail docking and ear cropping are illegal in many countries, including much of Europe. This is due to the belief that these procedures are cruel and unnecessary, and do not provide any medical benefit to the dog.

In my personal opinion, I think it's best to avoid tail docking and ear cropping altogether. Our pets' health and well-being should always be our top priority, and unnecessary surgeries should be avoided whenever possible. While there may be some exceptions where these procedures are necessary for medical reasons, such situations are relatively rare.


Hi everyone! As a Rottweiler owner, I can provide some insight into why the tail and ears are sometimes docked/cropped. Historically, these procedures were done for practical purposes such as protecting the dogs during hunts and battles. Additionally, docking the tail provided a clear line of sight for the dogs when herding cattle.

However, nowadays, many people opt to dock/crop for cosmetic reasons, influenced by breed standards and show dog competitions. While these procedures can certainly enhance the breed's appearance, it's important to remember that they are invasive surgeries that carry risks, and should not be taken lightly.

Personally, I chose not to dock or crop my Rottweiler's tail or ears, as I see no practical justification for it in today's world. My dog is happy and healthy without any alterations to his appearance, and I would never want to subject him to unnecessary pain or risk.

In the end, it's up to each individual owner to decide whether or not to dock/crop based on their own personal beliefs and considerations for their pet's well-being.


Hello everyone! As a Doberman Pinscher owner, I did a lot of research before deciding whether to dock my dog's tail or not. While I ultimately decided against docking, I can understand why some people choose to do so.

Many Doberman breed standards call for a docked tail, and the look of the docked tail is part of their iconic appearance. However, as others have mentioned, the procedure can be painful for the dog and carries some risks, such as infection and nerve damage.

I think it's important to consider the reasons behind docking a dog's tail and determine whether it's necessary or just for aesthetic purposes. In my case, I did not plan on using my dog for any working activities that would put them at risk for tail injuries, so I did not see any practical reason to dock.

Ultimately, the decision whether to dock a dog's tail or not comes down to personal preference and lifestyle factors. However, it's important to prioritize the dog's well-being over appearance and consider the risks and benefits of the procedure before making a final decision.

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community