Fetching Doberman Knowledge...

Our furry friends are worth the wait. We're fetching the latest and greatest Doberman information just for you. Thank you for your patience!

Popular Searches:

Would a Doberman or a Rottweiler be more suited to my lifestyle?

Hey guys,

I am in a bit of a dilemma here. I am planning to adopt a dog, preferably a Doberman or a Rottweiler. However, I am not sure which one of the two breeds would be more suited to my lifestyle.

A little about myself: I work a 9-5 job and am usually away from home for about 8 hours a day. I have a decent-sized yard but no children at home. I do enjoy being active and going on long walks, but I am not an overly outdoorsy person. I also have a housekeeper who comes in twice a week.

I want a dog that is protective but not overly aggressive, loyal, and good with strangers, especially children. I also want a dog that can handle being alone for long periods of time without getting overly anxious or destructive.

I have done some research on both breeds, and while they both seem like amazing dogs, there are some differences that I am not sure how to weigh. Dobermans are more high-energy and require more exercise, while Rottweilers are more laidback and tend to be more protective. However, I am not sure which would be the better fit for me.

Which breed do you guys think would be better suited for my lifestyle? I would appreciate any advice or personal experiences you can share. Thanks in advance!

All Replies


Hey there!

I have experience raising both Dobermans and Rottweilers, and based on your lifestyle, I would recommend going with a Rottweiler.

While Dobermans are amazing dogs and incredibly loyal, they require a lot of exercise and attention to keep them happy and healthy. If you are not an overly outdoorsy person, you might find it difficult to provide a Doberman with the amount of exercise they need. In addition, without proper exercise, they can become destructive and anxious.

Rottweilers, on the other hand, are more laidback and require less exercise than Dobermans. They are still active dogs and enjoy going for walks and playing, but they won't be bouncing off the walls if they don't get enough exercise. They are also incredibly loyal and protective, making them great family dogs. However, they can have a bit of a stubborn streak, so it's important to start training them early on.

Overall, I think a Rottweiler would be a better match for your lifestyle. They are great with children and strangers when socialized properly, and they can handle being alone for long periods of time without getting anxious or destructive. Of course, it's important to do your own research and meet with breeders or rescue organizations before making a final decision.

Hope this helps!


Hi everyone,

I have experience owning both Dobermans and Rottweilers, and I think it ultimately comes down to what you want out of a dog. Dobermans are high-energy dogs that require more exercise and mental stimulation. They are more agile and active, making them great for owners who like to get outside and play. Rottweilers, on the other hand, are more laid-back and protective, making them better for owners who want a dog that will be a companion and guardian.

Regarding the lifestyle, Dobermans are more challenging to handle and need much more exercise than Rottweilers. They are great for owners that have the time and energy to take them for daily runs or extended walks. They are also known for their loyalty, affection, and love for their owners. Rottweilers, however, can handle being alone for a more extended period of time and need less exercise. They are less hyper and more protective of their owners and family.

In my experience, both breeds are affectionate, loyal, and intelligent dogs. Dobermans are fearless watchdogs that require lots of socialization, training, and exercise to become the perfect companion. Similarly, Rottweilers are known for their strong protective instinct and loyal nature, making them great family dogs.

In conclusion, I believe that the decision to choose between a Doberman and a Rottweiler should be based on your personal preference, lifestyle, and what type of companion or watchdog you want. Both breeds have their great qualities, and you can't go wrong with either of them. Just make sure to research and choose a reputable breeder or rescue organization.



I own a Rottweiler and I believe it would be a better fit for your lifestyle. Although they require daily exercise and mental stimulation, they are generally laid back and can handle spending time alone more than Dobermans. Rottweilers are known for their loyalty and protective nature, making them great with families and children. They are also intelligent and easy to train, so you can teach them to behave well and stay calm around strangers.

Rottweilers are also great indoor pets as they have a relatively low activity level, making them suitable for smaller homes, apartments, or condos. They enjoy lounging on the couch as much as going for a walk or playing at the park with their owners. They are less energetic and less demanding than Dobermans, which is why they may be a better fit for people with 9 to 5 jobs who may not have as much time to dedicate to their pets.

That being said, Rottweilers do require socialization from a young age, as well as daily exercise and mental stimulation to stay healthy and happy. They can become destructive or anxious if left alone for an extended period of time, so be sure to provide them with the care and attention they need. If you are looking for a family member that will be loyal, protective, and calm, a Rottweiler may be a great choice.

Of course, whatever breed you choose, be sure to seek out a reputable breeder or rescue organization that can provide you with a healthy and well-behaved dog. Good luck with your search!



I also have experience raising both Dobermans and Rottweilers, and I believe that a Doberman would fit your lifestyle better.

Although Dobermans are high-energy dogs, they can adjust well to being alone for longer periods of time, especially if they are given enough exercise and mental stimulation. They are incredibly loyal and form strong bonds with their owners, making them great family dogs. In terms of exercise, a Doberman would be more challenging than a Rottweiler, but it is nowhere near impossible to meet their exercise needs. A 30-minute walk and some playtime in the yard each day should suffice. In fact, Dobermans are more likely to enjoy challenging activities such as agility training, which can be great fun for both you and your dog.

One thing to note is that Dobermans can be more high-strung than Rottweilers, and they can sometimes be nervous around strangers or new situations. Proper socialization and training from puppyhood can help to mitigate these tendencies, but you must be willing to put in some effort to ensure that your Doberman grows up to be a well-adjusted dog.

Overall, I think either breed would do well with you, but given your love for exercise, I would recommend a Doberman.


Hello everyone!

As an experienced Doberman owner, I would like to share my perspective on this topic. While Dobermans are high-energy dogs and require plenty of exercise, they can adapt well to different lifestyles, including those of working professionals. With the proper training and attention, they can learn to enjoy alone time and not become anxious or destructive when left alone. They also make excellent watchdogs and are extremely loyal to their families.

I do agree that Dobermans require quite a bit of exercise, but I would not describe them as overly demanding. In fact, they can make great apartment pets as long as they get enough daily exercise, both physical and mental. A walk in the morning and another one in the evening, plus playtime in the yard or indoors, should be enough to keep them happy and healthy.

Dobermans can also be described as more sensitive and in tune with their owner's emotions than other breeds. They love to be with their families, but they are also independent thinkers and require specific training techniques to achieve optimal behavior. With the proper training, they can behave well around kids and strangers and can be a perfect pet for any family.

Ultimately, the decision between a Doberman and a Rottweiler comes down to your personal lifestyle and preferences. Both breeds are amazing dogs and require a lot of care and attention, but with the right training and structure, any dog can make an excellent companion. Just make sure you do thorough research and are prepared for the responsibility that comes with owning a dog.



I may be able to give a different perspective as someone who has owned both a Doberman and a Rottweiler. In terms of your lifestyle, I believe that a Rottweiler would be the better fit.

My Doberman was incredibly high-energy and required a lot of exercise and attention, which sounds similar to what you've read about the breed. They have a lot of power and need an outlet to release that energy, which can make them destructive and anxious if not provided with enough stimulation. On the other hand, my Rottweiler was more laidback and required less exercise to keep her happy and healthy. She was more than happy to curl up on the couch beside me while I worked or watched TV, whereas my Doberman always needed to be moving and playing.

That being said, both breeds are protective, loyal, and love children. It really comes down to your personal preference and willingness to provide adequate exercise and training. If you're willing to commit to daily walks and playtime, a Doberman could work well for you. But if you're looking for a dog that's a little easier to handle in terms of exercise and energy level, a Rottweiler might be the better choice.

At the end of the day, it's important to spend time with both breeds before making a decision. Each individual dog can have its own personality and temperament, so it's important to find the one that meshes well with your lifestyle and personality. Good luck with your decision!


Hello all,

As a Rottweiler owner, I would recommend a Rottweiler as a better fit for someone with a 9 to 5 job as they are more laid back and can handle being alone for longer periods than a Doberman. Rottweilers are also notoriously good with children and make excellent family dogs. They can be described as gentle giants because of their protective nature and their extreme loyalty to their family. They are also not overly dependent on their owners and can be left alone for several hours at a time without causing any destruction in the house.

However, Rottweilers do require a good amount of exercise to keep them happy and healthy. They love long walks and hikes with their owners, but they are not as high-energy as Dobermans. They are also known for drooling and shedding more than Dobermans, which can be an issue for some owners.

In the end, it comes down to personal preference and lifestyle. If you have a lively household with kids and are an active person who can commit to providing more exercise to keep your dog active and happy, go for a Doberman. If you are looking for a more laidback, protective breed that is great with kids and can handle being alone for extended periods, go for a Rottweiler.

Whatever breed you choose, make sure to do your research and find a reputable breeder or rescue organization to ensure that you get a healthy, well-adjusted dog that will fit in well with your lifestyle.


Hello everyone!

As a long-time dog owner, I had experience both Dobermans and Rottweilers. In my opinion, choosing between these two breeds mostly comes down to personal preferences.

Dobermans are active and agile dogs that require daily exercise and mental stimulation. While they can do well in homes with a backyard or access to outdoor activities, they can also live in apartments or smaller homes as long as they receive enough physical exercise and mental stimulation. However, the Doberman's energy level might be a better fit for someone more active or willing to commit time to long walks and play. As an indoor pet, Dobermans also tend to shed less and have less tendency to drool than Rottweilers.

On the other hand, Rottweilers are a bit more laid back and tend to be more protective of their families. They are known for their loyal and affectionate personalities, as well as their natural watchdog tendencies. As long as there is enough space for them to move around, Rottweilers can adapt well to apartments or smaller homes. However, they also require daily exercise to maintain their health - and again, they are usually more affectionate and make excellent watchdog.

Ultimately, as you can see there's no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, and the decision to choose between a Doberman and a Rottweiler should be based on your lifestyle, personality, and preferences. Whatever breed you select, make sure to do your research and find a reputable breeder or rescue shelter. Believe me when I say that having a loyal companion to share life with is a joy that is immeasurable!

New to Doberman Wiki Community?

Join the community