Are Male or Female Dobermans Better Guard Dogs?

When choosing a guard dog, there are many factors to consider; size is the most critical factor for some people. Others prioritize strength or aggression. However, one of the most important considerations is gender. So, are male or female Dobermans better guard dogs? The answer depends on what you’re looking for in a guard dog. A male Doberman is usually the better choice if you’re looking for strength. Dobermans are well-known for their loyalty, obedience, and fearlessness. They are often used as guard dogs, and their reputation as excellent protectors is well-deserved. They are larger and have more muscles, making them better able to defend their territory. However, if you’re looking for loyalty and protection, a female Doberman is often better. Ultimately, the best guard dog is the one that best suits your needs.

Male Vs. Female Doberman Dogs Overview

Many people wonder whether a male or female dog would make a better guard dog when choosing a Doberman. Both male and female Dobermans can make excellent guard dogs, but they have different strengths to consider when making your decision. While both sexes have their unique strengths and weaknesses, some general tendencies can be observed. For instance, males tend to be more aggressive and territorial, while females are typically more loving and protective of their families. In terms of size, males are also generally larger and stronger than females, making them better suited for guard work. However, females often have keener senses of smell and hearing, which can come in handy when guarding against potential threats.


One of the most obvious differences between male and female Dobermans is size. Males are typically larger than females, often weighing 10 to 15 pounds more. This extra size gives them a physical advantage when guarding their territory. They are also generally more muscular, giving them the strength to take down an intruder if necessary.

On the other hand, females tend to be smaller and more delicate. This can be a disadvantage if they are faced with a large or aggressive intruder. However, it also means they are less likely to injure someone they perceive as a threat unintentionally. This can be important if you have young children or other family members who might be mistaken for an intruder.


Another difference between male and female Dobermans is strength. Males are typically stronger than females due to their larger and muscular build. This extra strength can be helpful when it comes to defending against an intruder. On the other hand, females tend to be more agile than males. This can be helpful if they need to escape from a dangerous situation or chase down an intruder.


When it comes to aggression, male Dobermans tend to be more territorial and protective of their homes than females. They are also more likely to attack someone who poses a threat to their family. On the other hand, females are typically more loving and protective of their families. They are less likely to attack unless they feel that their family is in danger.


Both male and female Dobermans are incredibly loyal to their families. They will do whatever it takes to protect themselves from harm. However, females tend to be more loyal to their owners than males. They are more likely to bond with their owner and see them as a member of their family.


Dobermans are known for their intelligence, and both males and females are equally intelligent. They are quick learners and can be trained to perform various tasks.


When it comes to senses, male and female Dobermans are both very acute. However, females tend to have a keener sense of smell and hearing than males. This can be helpful when it comes to detecting potential threats.

Advantages of Male Doberman Dogs

Male Doberman dogs are often seen as better guard dogs than their female counterparts. There are several reasons for this.

  • First, males are usually bigger and more physically imposing than females. This can be a deterrent to would-be intruders, as they may think twice before trying to take on a large dog.
  • Male Dobermans tend to be more aggressive than females, which can be helpful when it comes to protecting property or loved ones.
  • Male Dobermans are better at general guard work, such as patrolling the perimeter of a property or guarding against intruders.
  • They’re generally more territorial than females, meaning they are more likely to defend their homes against intruders.
  • And they bond well equally with all the family members, not just one person.

See Also: How to Tell if your Doberman Loves you?

Advantages of Female Dobermans

  • One advantage of female Dobermans is that they tend to be more territorial than male Dobermans. Female Dobermans will guard their home and property more fiercely than their male counterparts. This is especially advantageous if you live in an area with a high crime rate or are worried about home invasions.
  • Female Dobermans are also less likely to wander off and get lost, making them better suited for families with small children.
  • In addition, female Dobermans tend to be more affectionate and easier to train than male Dobermans. As a result, they make great family pets.
  • Female Dobermans are more aggressive towards strangers than their male counterparts, but they are more likely to attack only if they feel their family is in danger.
  • Female Dobermans bond strongly with one person and are very loyal to their family. And they are better at personal protection work than their male counterparts.
  • They have a great sense of smell and hearing, which can help detect potential threats.
  • While there are some advantages to owning a Doberman, it is important to remember that each dog is an individual and that personality traits cannot be predicted with 100% accuracy. Therefore, choosing a dog based on temperament and compatibility is important rather than gender.

Female Dobermans as Guard Dog

  • Female Dobermans are better guard dogs for several reasons.
  • First, they tend to be more alert and aggressive than male dobies. They are also more territorial and will defend their home against intruders more fiercely.
  • Female Dobermans also tend to bond more strongly with their owners and are less likely to be distracted by other people or animals.
  • Female Dobermans mature faster than males and are typically better at following commands and learning new tricks. They are smaller in size, making them easier to handle. And it is easier to find a well-bred female Doberman than a male.
  • Finally, female Dobermans usually live longer than male Dobermans so that they can provide years of loyal protection.
  • Female Dobermans are the better choice for anyone looking for a guard dog for all these reasons.

Male Doberman as Guard Dogs

Male Dobermans are often seen as the better guard dogs because

  • Male Dobermans are naturally more aggressive. Their highly territorial nature makes them better suited for protecting yards or bigger properties.
  • Male Dobermans are also typically larger and stronger than their female counterparts, making them more intimidating to would-be intruders.

In addition, male Dobermans tend to be less distracted by things like food and other animals, making them better able to focus on their job of protecting their home.

  • They are very quick to get along with strangers, but they show their guard dog side if they sense any danger to their family.
  • However, they are very goofier. Male Dobermans can also be more difficult to train and may not be as good at following commands as female Dobermans.
  • In addition, Male Dobermans may be more likely to exhibit undesirable behaviors, such as excessive barking or aggression towards family members.

See Also: Can Dobermans Get Along with Cats?

Why are Dobermans considered to be the ideal Guard Dog?

Dobermans are the ideal Guard Dog for several reasons.

  • They are highly intelligent, fearless, and have a strong protective instinct. They are also very athletic and have a powerful build that can intimidate would-be intruders.
  • They are large and powerful, with a muscular build that can intimidate would-be intruders.
  • They are extremely loyal and will guard their owner’s property with their lives
  • They are powerful and athletic, making them more than capable of deterring would-be criminals.
  • They are relatively easy to care for, requiring only regular grooming and exercise.
  • They have a commanding presence that can help to deter potential threats.

Dobermans are considered one of the best breeds for protection and security. They are powerful, intelligent, and fiercely loyal to their family. For all these reasons, Dobermans make ideal Guard Dogs and are trusted companions for many homeowners. If you are looking for a Guard Dog, a Doberman is a great choice.

Training For Guard Work

Dobermans are one of the most popular choices for guard dogs, thanks to their loyalty, intelligence, and courage. But before a Doberman can become an effective guard dog, they need to undergo extensive training. Like all breeds, Dobermans have their unique personalities and temperaments, which must be considered when training them for guard work.

The first step is to socialize the dog to be comfortable around people and other animals. Then, they need to be taught basic obedience commands, such as sit, stay, come, and down. After that, they can start to learn more specialized skills, such as how to search for intruders and how to respond to different types of threats.

Dobermans are naturally protective, so they will usually understand guard work easily. However, it is important to make sure that they are properly trained to be effective guard dogs and trusted companions. To give proper training to your Doberman, you can enroll them in a training class or hire a professional trainer. You can also find many online resources that can help you train your Doberman for guard work.

IPO Training

Thanks to their large size, athletic build, and fearless nature, Dobermans are often used for guard work. However, it is important to remember that these dogs are not born with an instinct to protect their homes and families. To turn a Doberman into an effective guard dog, owners must provide proper training and socialization. IPO training is one of the most popular methods for training guard dogs. IPO stands for Internationale Prüfungs-Ordnung, and this is a specific form of training designed to teach a dog how to perform guard work. This type of training is often used with Dobermans, as they are naturally protective and have a strong work ethic. IPO training typically involves three phases: obedience, protection, and tracking. The dog is taught basic commands such as sit, stay, and come in the obedience phase. The protection phase teaches the dog how to defend its handler from an attacker. The dog is taught how to follow a scent trail in the tracking phase. IPO training can be very intense and requires a lot of dedication from both the handler and the dog. However, it can be an extremely rewarding experience for both parties involved.

Other Types of Training

Many different types of training can be used to teach Doberman guard work. However, IPO training is one of the most popular and effective methods. Other types of training that can be used include

  • Scent work is a great way to teach a Doberman to search for intruders. This type of training can be done using various scents, such as tobacco, gunpowder, or drugs.
  • Agility training is a great way to teach a Doberman how to be alert and responsive. This type of training can also burn off excess energy and keep the dog fit and healthy. During this training, the Dobermans will be taught to work closely with the owner and obey commands.
  • Dock diving is another great way to teach a Doberman how to be alert and responsive. This type of training involves the dog jumping into the water after a toy or object is thrown in. This is a great way to teach a Doberman how to be aware of their surroundings and stay focused on their task.
  • Obedience training is a great way to teach a Doberman how to follow commands. This type of training can also socialize the dog and build a bond between the handler and the dog.

See Also: How to Handle a Needy Doberman


Are Male or Female Dobermans Better Guard Dogs? It is hard to say because it depends on your personal needs and the dog itself. Some male Dobermans can be better, and some female Dobermans can be better. But in general, both males and females make great guard dogs if they are properly trained and socialized. Both have unique traits that can make them excel in different ways. It is important to remember that each dog is different and will have its unique strengths and weaknesses. The best way to find out if a Doberman is the right guard dog for you is by assessing your needs and meeting a professional to discuss which dog would be the best fit for your family

See Also: How to Prevent Separation Anxiety in Dobermans

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a Doberman cost?

Dobermans are expensive dogs. They can cost anywhere from $1000 to $2,000. However, the price of a Doberman will depend on many factors, such as the breeder, the bloodline, and the location.

Do Dobermans make good family dogs?

Dobermans can make great family dogs if they are properly trained and socialized. However, they may not be the best fit for families with small children as they can be very energetic and excitable. They are very loyal and protective of their families.

How much exercise does a Doberman need?

Dobermans are very active dogs and need a lot of exercise. They also enjoy playing fetch and going for swims. They should be taken on long walks or runs every day.

How big do Dobermans get?

Dobermans can weigh anywhere from 60 to 100 pounds. They are usually between 24 and 28 inches tall at the shoulder.

How long do Dobermans live?

Dobermans typically live between 10 and 12 years. However, some Dobermans have been known to live up to 15 years.

Are Dobermans easy to train?

Dobermans are bright and easy to educate, except that they might be stubborn from time to time. When it comes to training male and female Dobermans, the latter is easier to teach.

See Also: Why Dobermans Can Make Great Apartment Dogs

What is the best way to socialize with a Doberman?

The best way to socialize with a Doberman is to expose them to different people, places, and situations early. This will help them become well-rounded dogs that are not afraid of new things.

Are Dobermans dangerous?

Dobermans are not naturally aggressive or violent dogs. However, they can be dangerous if they are not properly trained and socialized. They are also protective of their families and may become aggressive if they feel that their family is in danger.

Do Dobermans bark a lot?

Dobermans do not typically bark excessively. However, they may bark when they are excited or sense something is wrong.

Do Dobermans shed a lot?

Dobermans do shed, but not as much as some other breeds of dogs. They typically shed twice a year, during the spring and fall.

Jason Morgan

Jason Morgan

I'm Jason Morgan, founder and author at I just love Dobermans - they're the best dogs in the world! I got my first Doberman, Max, when I was just a pup myself. Max was my loyal friend and protector for over ten years. Since then, I've been working hard to learn everything I can about these amazing dogs. I started DobermanWiki as a place to share all that knowledge with other Doberman enthusiasts like me. My goal is to help every Doberman owner have the best possible relationship with their dog. I'm always happy to chat with other Doberman owners, so feel free to reach out anytime!

Leave a Reply

Doberman vs. Great Dane : The Ultimate Canine Clash Doberman vs. Dalmatian: Spot the Difference Raising a Doberman Puppy: 9 Useful Tips Top 10 Doberman Exercises and Activity Ideas 9 Proven Ways to Form a Lifelong Bond with Your Doberman